How Different and Serious Are the Doping Charges Levied on Simona Halep From Maria Sharapova’s 2017 Ban?

Doping allegations in professional sports are not new, and tennis has seen its share of controversies. Two of the best names in tennis, Simona Halep and Maria Sharapova, have found themselves in the middle of doping scandals in their career. Both incidents came as shockers to their fans and even to themselves as well. However, the time period for which they got banned from the sport was completely different as were the charges were levied against them.

That being said, there’s always a question that keeps fans wondering. Which of the two players faced more serious charges? How different were the allegations leveled against the two? How did Sharapova’s ban affect her career and will the same spell doom for Halep too? Let’s find out!

Why were Simona Halep and Maria Sharapova banned from tennis?

When it comes to tennis, there are few who have made an ever-lasting impact on the sport like Maria Sharapova. However, the Russian player, who won five Grand Slams, experienced drama when she tested positive for the banned substance meldonium (used to improve blood flow) in 2016. Masha first tested positive for the substance back at the Australian Open when she lost against the mighty Serena Williams in the quarter-finals. Further developments then followed, after which she was handed a 2-year ban from the sport, which blindsided her career.

In her defense, she said that she had been using the substance for a long time and was unaware that the substance had then been recently banned. “I did fail the test, and I take full responsibility for it. … It’s very important for you to understand that for 10 years, this medicine was not on WADA’s banned list and I had been legally taking the medicine for the past 10 years. But on Jan. 1, the rules had changed and meldonium became a prohibited substance, which I did not know,” said Sharapova.

On the other hand, Simona Halep, a highly regarded Romanian tennis star, faced a doping charge that shook the tennis world. In August 2023, Halep was charged with a doping violation which handed her a 4-year ban from the sport. Apparently, she had been taking a supplement advised by her physiotherapist, which contained a banned substance called Roxadustat, which was used to treat anemia and increase endurance and recovery.

The panel that looked into Halep’s case believed that her case was sophisticated and repetitive. While many saw it to be intentional, Halep suggested that it was completely unintentional. After being tested positive back at the US Open in 2022, she was eventually handed a 4-year ban back in August. While these are the situations, many now wonder, which incident was more serious.

ALSO READ: 36-Year-Old Russian Tennis Beauty Maria Sharapova and Toddler Son Surprises ‘Papa Bear’ on His Special Day With a Sweet Message

Both Sharapova and Halep faced the ITIA’s wrath

Maria Sharapova’s doping case was largely defined by its timing and circumstances. She was at the top of her career when the scandal broke, making it a more high-profile case. However, it was due to her negligence about the recent addition of meldonium to the list of banned substances that made the case look more serious.

On the other hand, Halep, who had unknowingly used a banned substance faced a bigger time off the tennis courts after she was given a 4-year doping ban. When it comes to the time period, Simona Halep definitely faced the wrath of the authorities as she faced thrice the time off the court as Sharapova did.

Halep’s case involved a second doping charge related to her biological passport. This is a long-term monitoring system designed to detect changes in an athlete’s biological parameters that may indicate doping. On the other hand, Sharapova’s case was centered on a specific substance, meldonium. The nature of the charges differed significantly, with Sharapova’s case focused on a specific substance while Halep’s involved continuous monitoring.

Sharapova and Halep: Public scrutiny and career performances

The media and public reaction to these cases also differed. Sharapova faced a large amount of media attention and public scrutiny. Opinions werer divided between those who believed her claims of unintentional use and those who saw her as a cheater. In Halep’s case, the reaction was less intense, possibly due to her lower profile than Sharapova at the time. However, she also got a significant amount of coverage as it was the second biggest scandal that the tennis world saw after Maria Sharapova.

When it comes to the impact that it had on their tennis careers, both players fall in the same line. Sharapova’s suspension came at the peak of her tennis journey and it certainly affected her ranking and endorsements. In contrast, Halep’s case occurred when she was already an established player. However, when Sharapova made a comeback, she was not able to perform at her level best which indicated a loss of touch during her ban period.

Halep, who will be 35 when she comes out on the tennis courts after her doping charges might not be able to witness the same amount of success that she earlier did due to the age factor. Thus, the doping charges faced by Simona Halep and Maria Sharapova, though both significant, differed in terms of timing, circumstances, and the nature of the charges. What are your views on this? Who do you think faced more severe charges in the sport? Do let us know in the comments below!

WATCH THIS STORY: Roger Federer Fanboy and Budding Tennis Star Speaks Up About Serena Williams