Some MLB legends didn’t just dominate the diamond—they excelled in other sports too. From football and basketball to golf and soccer, these six players proved that their athletic skills went far beyond baseball. Let’s take a look at the MLB stars who could have thrived in a different sport!

6 MLB Legends Who Excelled In Another Sport Too

Before speedster Dee Gordon became an MLB All-Star, he was a talented basketball player. As a high-scoring guard, he had serious potential on the court, but his father—former MLB pitcher Tom Gordon—steered him toward baseball, fearing his height would hold him back in the NBA.

6. Dee Gordon (Baseball & Basketball)

A powerhouse at the plate, Matt Holliday was nearly an All-American football star instead. As a high school quarterback, he caught the attention of top recruiters. But with baseball in his blood, he ultimately chose the St. Louis Cardinals over the football field.

5. Matt Holliday (Baseball & Football)

Kyle Lohse wasn’t just a pitcher—he was also a skilled golfer. While he dabbled in football and basketball in his younger days, golf became his second passion. He even competed in the Golf Channel Amateur Tour, nearly winning the West Valley Championship.

4. Kyle Lohse (Baseball & Golf)

With his towering 285-pound frame, Adam Dunn looked every bit like a football player. Initially recruited as a quarterback for the Texas Longhorns, he seemed destined for the gridiron. But baseball came calling, and he made a name for himself as a feared slugger in the majors.

3. Adam Dunn (Baseball & Football)

Before becoming a Yankees legend, Alex Rodriguez was a star quarterback at Westminster Christian High School. He even received a Division I offer from the University of Miami. Though he stuck with baseball, his football roots never faded—even playing during an injury rehab stint!

2. Alex Rodriguez (Baseball & Football)

Not many people know that Yankees captain Derek Jeter had a passion for soccer. Though he chose baseball, his mentality was still shaped by the sport. His ability to read plays, capitalize on opponent mistakes, and even his dramatic flair on the field were all influenced by his soccer background.