Shaking the foundations of Annapolis, a recent ruling by the legal authorities has burdened it with hefty fines. After a tragic accident portrayed brutal impacts on a native cyclist, no one could ever imagine how far its course would spread. While the cycling enthusiast had to undergo a dreadful recovery, the city’s recurring appeals further delayed his justice.
But a beacon of hope unveiled itself when the latest verdict on the case was made by the Appellate Court of Maryland. Standing in favor of the cycling addict Matthew W. Hager, the management of Annapolis was directed to pay him a staggering fine as compensation. While the total amount ranged nearly $350k, it took years for Hager to win his righteous equity. Guess how long the wait was? 6 years!
Watch What’s Trending Now!
Unsafe drain grate setup causes cycling collision
In June 2017, the unsuspecting man was cycling along the Chinquapin Round Road when a catastrophic bike crash left him grappling with pain. Evidently, Hager’s harrowing injuries stemmed from a storm drain grate with a gap, which exceeded the highway administration’s permissible width.
With its more than an inch breadth clashing the standards that allowed only a half-inch clearance, this spacing eventually led to his calamitous fall. Despite his boundless suffering, Hager’s quest for compensation was initially met with resistance from the city’s attorneys.
Regrettably, they not only offered no settlement for the cycling victim but also sought summary judgment against him. After this attempt failed in court, the city again engaged in a trial in April 2022, only to face defeat once more. Despite its post-trial motions to alter the outcome, the appellate legal stand remained firm in the current decision.
Much-awaited conclusion turns in favor of resident
Additionally, internal emails unveiled during the trial even exposed the city’s negligence, featuring its awareness of the faulty grates for five years without corrective actions. While their assistant attorney, Joel Braithwaite, urged for a new trial to reduce the damages, he was even open to a reversal of the verdict.
However, Braithwaite’s stance was met with denial from Judge Richard R. Trunnell, who issued a comprehensive 60-page opinion affirming the ruling. With the legal expenses totaling $272,000, which was more than a potential $75,000 settlement five years prior, the city refrained from seeking further legal recourse.
Having plans to pay the amount from a self-insurance fund, they had to clear the jury’s entire demands for the cycling man. While the 2022 decision asked for $300,000, a further addition of $47,000 was made due to the city’s persistent appeals that delayed justice. Cycling enthusiast Matthew W. Hager, now residing in California, was finally about to get his long-deserved compensation, thanks to the court’s firm judgment.
In a nod to accountability, they quoted a landmark 1901 case, asserting that municipal authorities must actively ensure safe public conditions. With all storm drains aligned with SHA guidelines, the city now pledges to continue regular inspections in an earnest attempt to prevent any more such incidents.
Watch This Story: The 5 most extensive cycling routes in England
Written by
Edited by
Arnima Shukla