Sometimes, a single incident is all it takes to tip over an entire weight class. Such an incident happened in January when the top 133-pounder from Lehigh suffered a broken elbow. Yet the All-American with a 5-0 record sat on top of InterMat’s NCAA rankings in February despite not competing since December 2024. Unfortunately, the wrestler himself has extinguished the final flame of hope that his fans held on to.

In a game-changing social media post for his division, star wrestler Ryan Crookham confirmed what many had feared. “I will not be competing this post season.”  Despite his eagerness and best efforts to bounce back, it turns out you can’t overcome a broken elbow so easily. “I’ll be ready next fall to make a run for that title,” announced the sophomore.

Naturally, the college wrestling community was devastated to learn that the Lehigh star wouldn’t be back before 2026. However, no one wanted to see last year’s third-place finisher put his entire career at risk just to chase this year’s title. “Prayers up,” one fan commented on the NCAA wrestler’s post on X, wishing him a swift recovery.

While Ryan Crookham’s post was the final nail in the coffin of his 2024/25 national title dreams, the post didn’t catch fans off-guard. Even the most optimistic fans didn’t think the wrestler would be able to bounce back before the end of the year. Some even suggested that the Mountain Hawk should look for ways to get a redshirt.

“Better to apply for medical rs if possible,” commented one fan when the news first surfaced in early January. Now it seems that the NCAA star may have been looking for ways to recover in time to participate in the postseason. Unfortunately, that comeback will have to wait till 2026 rolls around. Needless to say, the fans are ready to wait.

The NCAA division gets interesting amidst Crookham’s absence

While losing Crookham was a huge blow for the EIWA, the fans assured they’d be there to cheer Crookham throughout his recovery and beyond. “I’m so sorry Ryan. Heal well and can’t wait to see you back better than ever,” commented one college wrestling fan. While the netizen was devastated by the news, he advised Crookham not to rush the recovery.

However, Ryan Crookham’s absence now gives his rivals like Drake Ayala, Lucas Byrd, and others the perfect chance to capitalize on the opportunity. In fact, even the fans were astounded to see Ayala below Crookham after the wrestler posted a 15-1 overall record during the 2024-25 regular season. Meanwhile, others like FloWrestling have kept Ayala on top of their NCAA rankings for the past few weeks.

Regardless, the fans believe that Ryan Crookham’s comeback will be one of the books. A few even made some bold predictions about the 133-pounder’s future. “Not the news that anybody wanted for you. Your NCAA title is inevitable,” commented one fan, stating the injury is only a hurdle before reaching the ultimate goal.

While others weren’t so bold with their predictions, everyone believes bigger accolades await Crookham in the future. “Big comeback in 2026,” commented another. The Lehigh sophomore, who has been getting such heartfelt support since announcing his injury, preemptively thanked his supportive fans.

“Appreciate all the support and love,” the former EIWA champion wrote in his post. He also cheered on Lehigh wrestling, concluding his announcement with “Go hawks” on X. And while fans continued to leave comments like, “Can’t wait for your comeback!!! Till then heal well,” things may get complicated for the Mountain Hawks before the NCAA star returns next season.

The NCAA.com predicted that Crookham’s teammates, such as Matty Lopes, may slot into the lineup in his absence. Who do you believe will emerge as the champion as Ryan Crookham is now out of the picture? Tell us in the comments.