The world is changing, and so are sports. While efforts to make sports more inclusive have become common, controversies still cannot be entirely avoided. With women’s volleyball being one of the most popular collegiate sports in the USA, it’s only natural that it attracts significant attention. However, this attention can also stir up controversy, as a recent issue has once again demonstrated.

The question of allowing transgender athletes to compete freely is a slippery slope that requires careful navigation. While some resolutions have been reached in various sports, others are still working out the finer details. Now, the prestigious NCAA is facing another troubling situation, reopening the floodgates to a fresh debate.

A whirlpool shakes the volleyball scene

Last weekend, volleyball fans were treated to some thrilling moments as the Santa Clara Tournament took place. While loyal followers of the sport anticipated an exciting event, the inclusion of San Jose’s Blaire Fleming—who was born biologically male but is on the Spartans’ women’s volleyball roster—raised many eyebrows. This decision did not sit well with Southern Utah, one of SJSU’s opponents, who ultimately chose not to compete against them

An article by OutKick from September 14 sheds light on the decision by the Thunderbirds. “The Southern Utah University volleyball team has opted to compete in just two non-conference games at the Santa Clara Tournament this weekend,” the school said in an official statement. While both programs refused to elaborate on the matter, it seems to have garnered attention from others who share the concern.

The mother of an NCAA athlete expressed her apprehension about having to see her daughter face a transgender opponent in the upcoming season. “These poor girls—they have been asked to make very uncomfortable decisions,” said April Chainey, mom of an Idaho volleyball star. However, not everyone seems to share her skepticism.

Contrasting takes on the issue muddy the water

The community has been divided ever since the row between Southern Utah and San Jose came to light. While many have expressed their dissatisfaction over Fleming’s inclusion in the women’s squad, others believe the possibilities of an amicable solution aren’t over yet. Considering how USA Boxing has decided to take a more lenient approach toward the issue, some fans opine that a similar path should be taken by the NCAA as well. While two-time SEC gold medalist swimmer and political activist Riley Gaines is keen on viewing the issue from a strictly biological standpoint, others have rallied behind Fleming without missing a heartbeat.

Albert slammed the University of Kentucky alum in a post on X as he fumed, “If I was Blaire Fleming I’d sue Riley…Riley really needs therapy.” Tony also believes that Fleming should take legal action against Gaines and anyone who raised suspicion over the volleyball player’s identity. Another fan went a step further to post an image of the SJSU women’s volleyball squad, urging critics to spot who among them is the player in question. This way, the fan hopes, stigma can removed on transgender athletes.

Which side of the spectrum do you fall in? Share a comment below to elaborate on your take on the matter!