Playoff hockey in Toronto hits different, and Game 1 of the Battle of Ontario proved exactly that. The Maple Leafs didn’t just dominate the scoreboard in a commanding 6-2 win over the Ottawa Senators—they took control of the entire building. And nothing captured that more than the echoing chant from the crowd: “Brady sucks! Brady sucks!”

Brady Tkachuk found himself the target of that energy all night long. And when asked about it postgame, he fired back without hesitation: “I guess I expected it. Couldn’t care less. I don’t really give a [expletive], to be honest. That’s not going to affect me.” It was the kind of tough talk you expect from a captain—but not everyone bought it.

Leafs’ experience overwhelms Ottawa’s nerves

For all the hype around Ottawa’s return to playoff hockey after seven years, Game 1 was a harsh reminder of what inexperience looks like under pressure. The Senators gave up six power-play opportunities—three of which Toronto converted—and racked up 38 penalty minutes, including undisciplined stretches from Ridly Greig, Tim Stützle, and even Brady Tkachuk himself.

Meanwhile, Toronto’s veterans handled the moment with the poise of a team that’s been here before. Mitch Marner, William Nylander, and John Tavares all scored. Auston Matthews dished out two assists. The Leafs didn’t just execute—they stayed composed. Head coach Craig Berube praised his team’s calm: “It definitely helps… knowing what to expect and how to keep your team composed.”

Brady Tkachuk, on the other hand, looked rattled. Despite landing five shots and seven hits, his roughing penalty and frustrated body language stood out more than anything. And while he insisted postgame that he was already looking ahead to Game 2, it wasn’t long before the hockey world turned his words into a meme—and his quote into a punching bag.

Fans don’t hold back after Brady Tkachuk’s “Couldn’t Care Less” comment

Tkachuk’s effort to downplay the chant quickly backfired online. His comment—“Couldn’t care less”—was immediately picked apart by fans who felt he showed exactly the opposite. One fan put it simply: “‘Could care less’ clearly cares LOL 😂.” It wasn’t just about phrasing—it was the tone, the timing, and the look on his face that told a different story.

Visibly frustrated in his postgame media appearance, Brady Tkachuk tried to keep the conversation on the team’s discipline issues. But fans weren’t buying the stoicism. “Imagine being an NHL player and something like that actually bothering you lol,” one fan posted, mocking the notion that a chant wouldn’t rattle a captain in his playoff debut.

The chant itself didn’t end with the game. It followed him onto social media, where Leafs fans doubled down: “Brady sucks 👏👏👏👏👏 Brady sucks 👏👏.” Within hours, it had turned into a meme, with fans flooding threads and TikToks with variations of the jeer. Game 1 didn’t just expose Ottawa’s nerves—it lit a fire under Leafs Nation.

Brady Tkachuk’s self-awareness about the team’s penalty issues—“We need to be more disciplined,” he admitted—wasn’t enough to shift fan focus. “Guy is such a whiner 😂 just like the fans crying about refs. Beautiful,” one post read, roasting both his on-ice composure and his postgame comments.

And of course, no hockey roast session is complete without someone taking it straight to the gutter. “Guy’s 25 and can’t even grow facial hair. Pathetic,” a fan wrote, leaning all the way into the chirping energy that playoff crowds live for. It was ruthless, over-the-top, and exactly the kind of energy that fuels a rivalry series.

With Game 2 coming up Tuesday night, one thing’s for sure—the crowd isn’t done. And unless Brady Tkachuk flips the script fast, the chants won’t just stick around—they’ll get louder.

Tkachuk says the noise doesn’t faze him. But Leafs fans say otherwise. Whether it’s online or in the arena, Toronto clearly got under his skin in Game 1—and they’re not letting up. The Senators looked undisciplined, unprepared, and emotionally overwhelmed. And now their captain is taking heat from every angle.

If Ottawa wants to punch back, it starts with Brady Tkachuk leading by example—not quotes. Because in Toronto, the only thing louder than “Brady sucks” is the silence when the scoreboard says otherwise.