As Conversations Emerge of Brock Purdy Being Nothing but a System QB, Is It Unfair Criticism or Do His Critics Have a Fair Point?

Debate on! Is Brock Purdy’s brilliance the result of a well-oiled football machine, or is he a standout NFL quarterback? The debate rages on as we delve into the 2022 NFL draft Mr. Irrelevant. Is he elite, or is he just a cog in the system? Shannon Sharpe, known for his unfiltered NFL insights, contends that Purdy isn’t the cream of the quarterback crop but a product of the system.

The discussion, courtesy of ESPN’s First Take, sheds light on how Purdy’s success appears linked to his supporting cast and coaching staff. One compelling point against anointing Purdy as elite is the relatively small number of games he’s started – just 13 in the regular season and playoffs. ESPN hosts argue he needs to prove his mettle over a more extended period.

Brock Purdy: A well-oiled football machine?

Yet, on the flip side, Purdy’s presence in MVP discussions, sharing a third place with the likes of Josh Allen, suggests he’s not to be dismissed lightly. ESPN’s top three contenders are Patrick Mahomes, Tua Tagovailoa, and Jalen Hurts, followed by Christian McCaffrey. The question looms: Why is Brock Purdy not an elite quarterback?

Sharpe attributes much of Purdy’s success to the 49ers‘ head coach, Kyle Shanahan, suggesting that without key playmakers like Deebo Samuel and Brandon Aiyuk, Purdy’s luster might dim. “He’s a product of the system,” Sharpe asserts, driving home his point.

But Sharpe doesn’t wholly dismiss Purdy’s prowess. He concedes that, within the 49ers’ system, Purdy ranks as a top-five quarterback and a strong MVP candidate.

Ryan Clark, another seasoned football pundit, takes a different stance. He considers Purdy not just a top-five quarterback within the system but also a top-two MVP candidate. In his view, “Right now, Brock is probably going to be your MVP and your Super Bowl champion. If that doesn’t make you Elite, then nothing else does.”

The looming Week 13 clash against the Philadelphia Eagles at Lincoln Financial Field promises to be a defining moment for Purdy.

The make-or-break game for Brock Purdy

Week 13 clash against the Eagles could determine whether the NFC’s top seed belongs to the 49ers. Chris Canty sees this as a litmus test, challenging Purdy to show his mettle and prove his elite status. “I’m going to fully believe in you [Purdy] being Elite now. You’re going to have an opportunity [in] week 13. You go back to the scene of the crime in Philadelphia.” Chris Canty challenged Purdy, “You can prove to me in that game whether or not you can be elite. That could determine who the number one seed is in the NFC once the playoffs kick-off.”

READ MORE – “As Much as Patrick Mahomes Does,” Despite Elevating Brock Purdy Into MVP Discussion, Shannon Sharpe Questions His Standalone QB ProwessO

On the other hand, Shannon Sharpe advocates for a test of Purdy’s mettle under adverse conditions. “I want to see him [Purdy] get uncomfortable, and then see if he can remain comfortable.” Sharpe wants to see if Purdy can maintain his composure when the going gets tough.

Conclusion: While the debate rages on whether Brock Purdy is an elite NFL, the upcoming games will play a pivotal role in determining his true status in the NFL hierarchy.

WATCH THIS STORY – JJ Watt Hails 49ers Front Office for Masterfully Building a Star-Studded Roster Across Various Positions