J.J McCarthy’s Sharp Rise in Draft Stock Surprisingly Labelled as “Over the Top” While Jayden Daniels Earns Bragging Rights

As the NFL Draft approaches, J.J. McCarthy’s stock continues to soar, surprising many who initially pegged him as a late first-round pick. Now, he’s a common fixture in the top ten of mock drafts, with some even ranking him as the third quarterback off the board. 

His impressive performance at the Combine, particularly during the throwing session, further solidified his standing. Other top quarterbacks like Caleb Williams, Drake Maye, and Jayden Daniels opted not to throw, putting McCarthy in the spotlight and amplifying the buzz surrounding his draft prospects. His sudden soar, however, has sparked speculation as well, with Matt and Phil Simms deeming the rise as “too much, too fast.”

Matt and Phil Simms discuss McCarthy’s rise

During The Sims Complete podcast, Matt Simms and Phil Simms dissect the sudden surge of J.J. McCarthy, the promising Michigan quarterback sensation. Recent reports suggested that J.J. McCarthy is now considered a potential selection for the Washington team with the second pick in the draft. However, there are concerns about the pressure and uncertainty surrounding his draft status, with comparisons drawn to previous draft scenarios involving notable quarterbacks like Aaron Rodgers. This raises questions about McCarthy’s role in the larger context of the NFL draft process and the dynamics at play behind the scenes. Simms opines that “this rise to me, I think it’s a little over the top,” and, “ too much too fast,” given the fact that he doesn’t match the amount of experience of the other quarterbacks in this draft class. 

He continues to say that, according to him, McCarthy does not rank as the second-best quarterback in this year’s NFL Draft. Instead, he expressed a preference for Jaden Daniels as the second-best quarterback option. Despite acknowledging McCarthy’s rapid ascent up the draft board, analysts remain skeptical about whether his performance merits the hype surrounding him. They express curiosity about whether McCarthy’s draft position reflects genuine talent or if it is primarily fueled by media attention and speculation.

McCarthy’s shocking ascend has everyone talking 

As the NFL Draft approaches, the discourse around J.J. McCarthy gains momentum. His standout performance at the NFL Combine, particularly during the throwing session, has only intensified the speculation surrounding his potential landing spot. Recent rumors reported by ESPN’s Dan Graziano suggest that McCarthy could be a top-ten pick, adding further intrigue to the story. Meanwhile, SNY’s Connor Hughes raised the possibility of the New York Giants selecting McCarthy with the sixth overall pick. Despite Daniel Jones currently leading the Giants’ offense, the allure of drafting McCarthy and grooming him behind Jones before eventually taking over could be an enticing proposition for the team’s future.

Read More: 2 Years After Deion Sanders Being Robbed, Colorado Players Suffered Similar Horrible Fate at UCLA

J.J. McCarthy’s ascent is also closely tied to the influence of Jim Harbaugh, his former coach at Michigan and current head coach of the Los Angeles Chargers. Harbaugh, having witnessed McCarthy’s growth firsthand, offered high praise for the young quarterback, calling his pro day performance “the best I’ve ever seen from a quarterback.” This endorsement from a seasoned figure in football speaks volumes about McCarthy’s talent and potential, solidifying his status as a top prospect in the upcoming NFL draft.