“Don’t Think He’s a Starting Quarterback”: Caleb Williams Advised to Sit Out Initially After the 2024 NFL Draft

As the 2024 NFL Draft approaches, USC quarterback Caleb Williams finds himself in the spotlight as a projected top pick. While the teams evaluate Williams, they must carefully weigh Ryan Leaf’s perspective on allowing for a measured development process rather than forcing an immediate on-field trial.

Properly acclimating a rare talent like Williams could prove crucial in unlocking his full potential as a franchise quarterback. The transition from college stardom to NFL success is often a challenging one, even for the most talented prospects.

Developing Caleb Williams: The Case for Patience with a Top QB Prospect

While Caleb Williams‘ electrifying play at USC has him projected as a top pick in the 2024 NFL Draft, a respected analyst Ryan Leaf cautions against thrusting the quarterback into a starting role too soon. The analyst’s advice stems from concerns that Williams’ college success may not immediately translate to the pro game, where he’ll need to adapt his playing style. 

 Leaf directly stated, “He needs some time. He needs to get under center, understand how to throw on time, on platform from the pocket.” While praising Williams’ talents, the evaluation highlights the quarterback’s need to hone pro-style skills like taking snaps under center and making timing throws from the pocket – areas he could bypass with his elite athleticism in college. 

“What he can do off-platform is what makes him so exciting…but he is a guy that I don’t think can be a starter on day one,” Leaf added. The implication is that Williams’ off-script playmaking may be neutralized early in the NFL before he masters operating from the pocket. The analyst pointed to Will Levis benefiting from a redshirt year as a potential blueprint for Williams. 

His concerns seem reasonable given the major differences between college and pro offenses. Williams thrived in USC’s spread system catered to his dual-threat abilities but will face a steep learning curve reading complex NFL defenses. Easing him in could prevent stunting his development by avoiding being overwhelmed too quickly and patience could pay off for Williams to reach his ceiling as a franchise quarterback. However, not all evaluators are as convinced Williams needs as long a runway before starting. The analyst’s dissenting views on other top quarterback prospects’ readiness highlight the varying perspectives on this draft class.

Jaden Daniels, Michael Penix Jr. Viewed as More NFL-Ready Options

While urging caution with Williams, the same Leaf tabbed Jaden Daniels and Michael Penix Jr. as prospects potentially capable of starting year one. “Those are the two guys I could see being a first-round pick that could start this season,” the analyst stated. Penix in particular drew high praise for his downfield accuracy and passing through medical evaluations after previous injuries. 

His strengths seem to align with what evaluators want to see from a pro-ready quarterback. His elite arm talent and proven ability to push the ball vertically could translate smoothly to the NFL game. Additionally, clearing medical hurdles eases concerns about Penix’s durability after two season-ending injuries at Indiana.  And those factors give him an edge over Williams in terms of immediate starter potential out of the gate. 

Read more: 2024 NFL Combine: Caleb Williams Breaks Silence on His Allegiance With Bears Amid Trade Rumors

Ultimately, the varying perspectives on Williams, Penix, and others illustrate the difficulty in projecting quarterback transitions from college to the pros. While Williams’ rare physical talents are tantalizing, the analyst’s reservations about his readiness seem prudent given the complexities NFL offenses present. Properly developing a prospect of his caliber could be vital for long-term success, even if it means initially having to be patient. What do you think? Let us know in the comments!