Carson Beck Steals Top Spot in NFL Draft Expert’s Preliminary List While Shedeur Sanders Snapped Back to Reality With Average Rating

Shedeur Sanders draft stock? More like a mocking club for draft analysts. On one hand, we have the NFL aficionados who think Shedeur Sanders would end up topping the QB class in the 2025 NFL draft class, pioneered by Deion Sanders. On the other, brutal scouting gurus and NFL draft experts are selling Shedeur Sanders’ draft picks short. Amid the tug of war, another QB has silently slithered his way to the top, quashing the proud claims of Shedeur Sanders and his father.

Carson Beck isn’t just posing as the starting QB of the heavyweight contender in the NCAA landscape this season. His season completion rate of 72.4% and 3941 passing yardage has made him the top QB on the top 16 preliminary QBs in the 2025 NFL draft board. Ian Cummings of PFN 365 gives him a rating of 8.50. Closely following him is the Houston QB Donovan Smith with an 8.16 rating. Jaxon Dart is next up with an 8.05 rating. But wait, Shedeur Sanders, the most buzzing QB in the 2025 NFL draft stocks, is nowhere to be seen in the first 3 places; a huge hit for the team supporting him.

Cummings ratings have placed Colorado’s Shedeur Sanders at No.4 with a 7.81 rating. The rankings were enough to give a massive reality check to Shedeur Sanders to come to terms with what to expect out of the NFL draft. The QB has received a good share of criticism from the scouting experts. From his confidence to his shortcomings, Shedeur Sanders’ strengths and weaknesses are dissected out in public. Will it be soon that the fans will hear the cracking sound from the confidence that Deion Sanders has in his son? While that remains awaited, it’s now time to dissect the strengths and weaknesses of the top QB on board.

Carson Beck: The selling points and shortcomings

The classic pro-style QB brings some of the finest pocket mechanics across the conferences. His mature pocket presence is a testament to his clean lane throws and elite torques. The confidence he comes with against the pass rush makes him the perfect example of a mature QB, a major luring point in the pro league. His 6-foot-4, 215-pound physique also looks ideal for the pro league. The best-selling point of Beck in the NFL would be his football IQ, enabling him to make quick decisions. Right from reading the situation to keeping the defenses guessing with his quick reaction, Beck would be a QB several teams would be chasing after.

The only thing those teams would need to consider is all these observations are from the single starting year Beck had under his belt. While his throws might be a sight for sore eyes, his release mechanics and pre-snap reads need some polishing to unlock that pro-level potential in the league. If any team would be ready to give that time and refinement to Beck, he would prove to be a jackpot for them. Not to mention, Beck still has a whole season at Georgia, the team that is expected to dominate the NCAA this season, under his belt to refine his skills further.