As the 2024 NFL Draft approaches, football enthusiasts, scouts, and fans are deeply engrossed in analyzing game tapes and evaluating players. One of the most discussed topics revolves around the perceived gap between USC’s Caleb Williams and North Carolina’s Drake Maye, both highly touted quarterback prospects projected as the top two picks in mock drafts.

Each player brings unique qualities to the table, showcasing their potential for success at the next level. However, there are also areas for improvement that have been identified early on. The debate over which quarterback should be considered the top prospect is ongoing, with opinions varying among experts and fans alike. Nonetheless, this discussion adds excitement and anticipation to the upcoming draft, shaping the narrative surrounding these talented athletes.

Will Caleb Williams be the No.1 draft pick?

Since his freshman campaign at Oklahoma, Williams has dominated the gridiron. He earned the highest grade among true freshman quarterbacks in the PFF College era, outperforming even a generational talent. His stellar performance continued into the recent season, where he secured the Heisman Trophy. Among Power Five quarterbacks, Williams ranked second with a grade of 91.6, recorded 32 big-time throws, led in passing touchdowns with 42, and ranked third in passing yards with 4,539.

A notable attribute of Williams is his improvisational skill, reflected in his impressive stats outside of the structured offense. With exceptional arm talent and agility, Williams can execute throws from various platforms, drawing comparisons to NFL star Patrick Mahomes. Standing at 6-foot-1 and weighing 220 pounds, he poses a challenge for defenders, often escaping sack attempts and forcing missed tackles on a significant portion of his rushing attempts, showcasing his strength and elusiveness on the field.

The anticipation surrounding Williams’s potential as the top pick in the upcoming NFL draft is palpable, with speculation on potential landing spots, including division rival Chicago or other teams. Meanwhile, rumors suggest a decline in Maye’s draft stock, leading to a slip down some NFL draft boards.

Drake Maye’s claim on the No.1 draft pick

Williams stands out for his electrifying playmaking skills outside the pocket, contrasting with Maye’s lethal precision within. Maye boasts an impressive 92.5 grade for his pocket presence last season, standing tall at 6-foot-4 and 225 pounds with a powerful throwing arm. His deep passing grade of 97.5 and 45 big-time throws topped the charts nationwide. Despite excelling within the pocket, Maye isn’t static; his 899 rushing yards and 535 yards after contact underscore his dual-threat capabilities.

Read More: 2 Years After Deion Sanders Being Robbed, Colorado Players Suffered Similar Horrible Fate at UCLA

While Williams may boast a higher forced missed tackle rate at 17%, Maye’s adeptness at handling pressure situations is evident in his record-setting 235 dropbacks under pressure. Both quarterbacks possess undeniable talent, each being a potential top pick in the 2024 NFL Draft, emphasizing the draft’s depth.

Choosing between them hinges on preference in quarterback style. Williams offers unrivaled independence in creating offense, while Maye excels in orchestrating from the pocket. Currently, Williams holds a slight edge due to his consistent elite performance over two seasons. Who do you think has the bigger edge?