Peyton Manning Reflects on High School Basketball Loss to Brother Eli: “Tough One to Swallow”

Peyton Manning is an NFL legend who shattered records throughout his career. His younger brother, Eli, also made his mark in the league as a quarterback for the New York Giants. Fans enjoyed the Manning rivalry on the field. Mostly, it was Peyton who always won the NFL matchups. Their first showdown in 2006 saw Peyton’s Colts win a close 26-21 game. They clashed again four years later, and the Colts secured a 38-14 victory.

However, the seeds of their on-field competition were sown long before their professional days. As high school students, the Mannings engaged in a fierce basketball rivalry, a testament to their competitive spirit that has transcended sports and become a part of their legacy. 

Peyton Manning opens up about a tough basketball loss 

In a recent YouTube Short, Eli and Peyton Manning shared a poignant moment, reminiscing about their long-standing basketball rivalry. Eli vividly recalled a head-to-head match with Peyton, a memory that still evokes strong emotions. The brothers used to play hoops whenever they visited their parents in New Orleans. “I remember that game quite well. I don’t think I’ve ever played any better,” Peyton said, his voice tinged with a mix of nostalgia and competitive spirit. Meanwhile, Eli couldn’t hide his pride as he added, “I dunked on him to win.”

However, their basketball rivalry was not meant to continue. Peyton then continued, “It was a disappointing loss. A tough one to swallow, the way it went down there at the end.” The siblings considered a rematch, but their dad, Archie Manning, a former quarterback, stopped it. “No more basketball. Y’all football players,” Archie declared. “So we haven’t got to play more,” Eli thus said. And so, the Manning brothers transitioned from basketball rivals to NFL legends, their high school basketball showdown serving as a poignant memory of their early days. 

The Manning rivalry: Battle of the brothers

The NFL witnessed three historic “Manning Bowl” clashes as the brothers faced off. Though Peyton won all three regular-season games, they remain tied with two Super Bowl wins. Peyton Manning was the top pick in the 1998 NFL Draft, joining the Indianapolis Colts. With them, he won his first Super Bowl in 2006, defeating the Chicago Bears.

Read More: “Thought That’s What He Was Known For”: Eli Manning Takes a Brutal Jab at Peyton in a Brotherly Banter During Pro Bowl Games

Meanwhile, Eli Manning followed his brother’s path to become a top draft pick in 2004. Not to be outdone, Eli led the New York Giants to a stunning Super Bowl victory a year later, ending the New England Patriots‘ perfect season. Eli even won another ring in 2011, again beating the Patriots, giving a tough fight for Peyton. It seemed Peyton might be stuck with just one ring for a while. However, he joined the Denver Broncos and finally captured his second championship. Despite their on-field battles, the Manning brothers have joined forces as hilarious Manningcast co-hosts. It’s clear they can work together brilliantly when they’re not competing.

Read More: Peyton Manning Helplessly Denies Career Advice to Tom Brady Because He Watches Football From His Neighbor’s Garage