Jerod Mayo’s head coaching journey with the Patriots started and ended with a win each. He wrapped up the season at 4-13. Robert Kraft decided to hit the reset button after just one season, a disappointing one. And this is the first time since 1990 that a Patriots coach was fired after their debut year. The big question now is: who’s next to take on the challenge?

Speculations are heating up. But the one name that towers above the rest—Mike Vrabel. The Patriots legend with proven coaching chops. But Vrabel isn’t the only contender. From offensive masterminds to defensive strategists, Kraft has an intriguing pool to choose from.

Jerod Mayo’s successor: Mike Vrabel and the case for a proven leader

Mike Vrabel stands as the favorite to succeed Mayo. He was a former Patriots star and Super Bowl champion. And his connection to New England makes him an obvious candidate. But it’s not just about that. His coaching résumé is what truly shines.

Vrabel’s time with the Titans speaks volumes. He led the team to a 54-45 record over six seasons. This includes a No. 1 AFC seed in 2021. He has an ability to build competitive teams, even with limited rosters. And this mirrors the Patriots’ need for a turnaround leader.

Kraft’s interest in Vrabel signals a shift. After Mayo’s unsteady debut, Kraft may prioritize stability and experience. “Mike Vrabel is expected to be among the candidates the #Patriots will interview for their head-coaching job, per @MikeReiss,” tweeted Andrew Callahan, echoing the sentiment.

But Vrabel isn’t just about numbers. His fiery personality and no-nonsense leadership could ignite the locker room. With ties to New England’s championship years (winning three for the Patriots – 2002, 2004, and 2005), he embodies the culture Kraft hopes to restore. That said, Vrabel isn’t the only name in the mix. Especially since there is news of him interviewing with the Jets as well.

Exploring the other four candidates

Beyond Vrabel, the Patriots have several options, each offering a unique vision for the team. Enter Brian Flores. Minnesota’s defensive coordinator and a familiar face in New England. With 11 years under Belichick as a defensive assistant, Flores knows the Patriots’ DNA. Flores brings a disciplined, blitz-heavy defensive style. His Miami tenure, though rocky, showcased his ability to elevate underwhelming rosters. The challenge? Convincing Kraft he can nurture young QB Drake Maye while fixing a shaky offense. Especially after his struggles with quarterback Tua Tagovailoa at Miami.

Offensive minds like Ben Johnson and Joe Brady also intrigue Kraft as Mayo’s replacement. Johnson, the Lions’ OC, helped transform Detroit into a scoring machine. His work with quarterback Jared Goff has turned heads. It turned a struggling passer into a Pro Bowl-level talent. And he could perhaps do the same for Maye. On the other hand, Brady has worked with some of the best quarterbacks in the game. This includes Joe Burrow and Josh Allen.

Brady was once the architect of LSU’s historic 2019 offense. And he offers creative solutions to unlock Maye’s potential. His ability to elevate quarterbacks makes him an interesting fit for the Patriots as they look to develop Maye into a future star. But who else?

There’s Pete Carroll. A veteran with ties to the Patriots, Carroll’s name carries weight. The current Seahawks head coach could be a wildcard. Though unlikely, his return would bring credibility to a franchise in flux. And his experience as a Super Bowl champion might prove invaluable.

Kraft’s decision will impact more than just the Patriots’ 2025 season. It’s a gamble on the team’s long-term identity, ensuring the choice isn’t just about replacing Jerod Mayo. It’s also about redefining the Patriots.