Home/NFL

via Imago

via Imago

0
  Debate

Debate

Is it time for the NFL to finally listen to the Rams' calls for reviewable penalties?

For NFL football fans, few missed calls have sparked as much controversy as this one. Even Rams‘ rookie Byron Young’s immediate reaction–hands-on helmet in an “oh, dang” pose–told the story of what everyone except the officials saw in the dying moments of Thursday night’s game at SoFi Stadium.

“We did not see it so we couldn’t call it,” referee Tra Blake explained in a post-game pool report about the game-sealing safety where Byron Young grabbed Vikings quarterback Sam Darnold’s facemask. The missed call sealed the Rams’ 30-20 victory with just 1:36 left on the clock.

Blake pulled back the curtain on the officiating crew’s limitations during the crucial play. “The quarterback was facing the opposite direction from me so I did not have a good look at it,” he detailed. “The umpire had players between him and the quarterback, so he did not get a look at it. He was blocked out as well.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

 

The Vikings‘ sideline erupted in protests, prompting on-field discussions among officials. Blake confirmed his crew talked it through after Minnesota’s concerns, but stood firm. Without a clear view, they couldn’t make the call. More frustrating for Vikings fans: the play wasn’t reviewable under current NFL rules.

This isn’t Blake’s first brush with Vikings-related controversy. Back in 2022, he officiated the Indianapolis Colts game where Minnesota completed the NFL’s biggest comeback – but not before his crew negated two legitimate scoop-and-score touchdowns by cornerback Chandon Sullivan.

What’s your perspective on:

Is it time for the NFL to finally listen to the Rams' calls for reviewable penalties?

Have an interesting take?

The rule change that could have changed everything

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

In an ironic twist, the benefiting team had seen this coming. The Rams submitted proposals to the NFL competition committee for three straight years, pushing to make facemask penalties, quarterback head hits, and roughing the passer calls reviewable. Each time, the league shot down the suggestion.

ProFootballTalk highlighted the current rule’s limitations on social media: “Yes, all scoring plays are reviewable. But because facemask calls are never reviewable, it doesn’t matter. If the officials miss it in real-time, there’s no way to fix it.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

The missed call didn’t erase an otherwise electric night at SoFi Stadium. Matthew Staffords four-touchdown performance, boosted by the return of receivers Cooper Kupp and Puka Nacua, lifted the Rams to their second straight win and a 3-4 record–just one game behind the division-leading Seattle Seahawks.

But as Albert Breer noted on social media, the night’s finish carried extra weight: “The irony in this missed call: The Rams sent proposals to the competition committee in each of the last 3 years to make penalties on facemasks to QBs, blows to the head and roughing the passer reviewable. Shot down every time, and LA benefitted tonight.” The incident adds fresh fuel to ongoing debates about expanding replay review in crucial game situations. Particularly for Byron Young and Darnold-like incidents.

Have something to say?

Let the world know your perspective.