In the wake of the 2023 season’s whirlwind of transactions, NFL teams have tasted the euphoria of a well-executed move – be it the 49ers’ strategic acquisition of Chase Young or the Eagles’ savvy strike for Kevin Byard. As the 2024 NFL draft board takes shape, whispers of blockbuster trades begin to rumble through war rooms across the league.
Teams like the Kansas City Chiefs and Buffalo Bills are supposedly poised to shatter last year’s trade record in an audacious bid for supremacy. According to Fox Sports’ Peter Schrager, “Teams who I could see movin’ on up tomorrow… Vikings, Broncos, Eagles, Chiefs, Lions, Jaguars, Colts, Patriots, Bills and Texans.” This bold stratagem signals a seismic shift from the 2023 draft mentality.
Teams who I could see movin’ on up tomorrow (check back for accuracy after the fact):
Vikings, Broncos, Eagles, Chiefs, Lions, Jaguars, Colts, Patriots (back into end of first round for a WR), Bills, Texans
— Peter Schrager (@PSchrags) April 25, 2024
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad
As Andy Reid said in an interview with SI, “There is a tremendous amount of input that goes into this first-round pick.” But with Patrick Mahomes‘ Chiefs valuing a long-term offensive line solution and the Bills facing a dearth of receiving threats after trading Stefon Diggs, the stakes are higher than ever to make that franchise-altering move.
The impetus is clear – the 2023 trade season rewrote the playbook with over 30 seismic deals. Teams across the league made trades for 10 players on the trade deadline day alone. As Reid quipped about the dizzying array of mock drafts, “I’ve got to give the guys credit. They’re all a little different.” Well, this draft night promises to be unique in its own right, a rebirth of “go big or go home” mentality.
But inherent risks lurk behind such aggressive maneuvering. As the Bills ponder trading up for a receiver like Rome Odunze, they must weigh the rewards against the sobering reality of past draft whiffs like Eagles GM Howie Roseman’s decision to draft Jalen Reagor over Justin Jefferson in 2020. The ever-changing NFL chessboard demands a deft mastery of the art of the deal, balanced against prudent roster-building.
NFL Draft: Balancing risk and reward
The high-stakes chess match of the NFL draft forces teams into a delicate dance – go big and swing for the fences or play it safe, minimizing collateral damage. As Chris Ballard draft approach about the Colts’ has been analyzed by ESPN, “This also hasn’t been a team that values cornerback as a premium position, so going after one in Round 2 seems more likely.”
For every franchise-altering pick, there are equal parts caution from past whiffs haunting draft rooms. The Chiefs’ own Veach took Clyde Edwards-Helaire rather than Tee Higgins, Michael Pittman Jr., and D’Andre Swift in 2020. As Mina Kimes warned about a potential Bills trade-up for Odunze, “That would be an entirely reasonable move if Buffalo believes Odunze is going to be a superstar.”
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad
The parable of the 2017 49ers further exemplifies the conundrum – taking Solomon Thomas third overall when Christian McCaffrey and Mahomes lingered. As Reid admitted, “There is a 50% success rate over a period for these first-round picks.” A humbling reality check amid the mock draft chaos.
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad
Yet, the ultimate contingency plan may be to go full Moneyball – trade down and amass assets like the Packers and Chiefs’ rebuilt receiver corps post-Davante Adams and Tyreek Hill trades. As Reid said, “You’ve really got to stay intact with the whole board.” Because in this gridiron theater of dreams, franchise fortunes can swing on a single, audacious trade-up or trade-down.