The NFL offseason is like a poker table. Some teams bluff, some fold, and some go all-in. The Seahawks? They might be pushing their chips into the middle with DK Metcalf, and the team sitting across from them? The Packers. Yeah, you read that right.

Rumors are swirling that the Seahawks are shopping Metcalf, and Green Bay is making serious moves to land the star wideout. And if the reports are true, Seattle could be sending their prized receiver straight into the hands of a $6.3 billion NFC rival. Feels a little personal, doesn’t it?

Let’s be real—the idea of Metcalf leaving Seattle would’ve been laughable a year ago. But with Pete Carroll gone, a new coaching staff in place, and a cap situation uglier than a botched flea flicker, the Seahawks are in a tough spot. They need financial breathing room, and Metcalf’s $31 million cap hit in 2025 isn’t exactly helping.

Enter Green Bay. The Packers are reportedly dangling a “high pick and a young receiver” to get the deal done, per Emerald Spectrum reporter Corbin Smith. And honestly? It makes too much sense. Christian Watson’s knee exploded at the worst possible time, and Jordan Love needs a WR1 who can beat man coverage when the game’s on the line. Metcalf fits that bill like a custom-tailored suit.

But is he worth it? That’s the big question.

Metcalf hasn’t averaged over 70 receiving yards per game since 2020, and his 1.88 yards per route run last season ranked 44th in the league—behind Jakobi Meyers and three different Packers. So while he’s a physical freak, he hasn’t exactly been the guy lately.

Then there’s the money. Trading for Metcalf means Green Bay wouldn’t just be giving up draft capital—they’d have to extend him, likely at around $32 million per year. That’s a whole lot of cheddar for a guy who hasn’t put up WR1 numbers in a while.

So what’s the move here? For Seattle, it’s about maximizing value. If they let Metcalf walk in free agency next year, they get nothing but a compensatory pick. Trading him now clears cap space and brings in assets. For Green Bay, it’s about going from good to great. Love is on the verge of something special, and giving him a legitimate No. 1 receiver could be the final piece.

Bottom line—this deal makes sense for both sides. The only question is whether the Seahawks are ready to hand their best receiver over to an NFC powerhouse. Because if this trade happens, Metcalf might just be catching passes against Seattle come playoff time. And that’s a sight Seahawks fans might not be ready for. Forget the fans, even Geno Smith might not like it (if he does extend his stay in Seattle). 

Trade for DK Metcalf and extend Geno Smith?

The Seahawks, DK Metcalf, and the Packers are making a perfect NFL modern-day love triangle… Endless rumors, no substantiation. The Packers have reportedly shown interest, even dangling a high draft pick and a young receiver in return. But Seattle hasn’t put Metcalf on the trade block. Head coach Mike Macdonald made that clear, saying the star wideout remains a focal point of their offense. That’s not exactly a firm ‘no’, but it’s not a ‘yes’ either. You know how this time of year works—smoke screens are everywhere.

And then there’s Geno Smith. Seattle is weighing whether to extend him beyond 2025. With one year left on his deal, he’s set to carry a massive $44.5 million cap hit. That’s a number the front office would love to tweak, but how much do they believe in him long-term? GM John Schneider played it cool at the combine, saying they’ll “see where it goes.”

Not exactly a ringing endorsement, but also not shutting the door on keeping him around. If an extension happens, it’s likely before free agency—otherwise, things could get messy fast. Now, let’s talk dollars. Smith’s $25 million per year ranks 19th among QBs—not exactly franchise money.

But he’s led nine game-winning drives in the past two seasons, tied for the most in the league. He’s earned a raise, but how much? The market for quarterbacks is skyrocketing, with even mid-tier guys getting $30 million-plus. The Seahawks know this, but they also know Smith’s 34 and coming off an up-and-down season. If they extend him, it’ll be at their price, not the top of the market.

And what if Seattle lets Smith play out his deal? That’s risky. A strong season could drive his price even higher. A mediocre one could leave the Seahawks scrambling for a QB in a weak draft class. Meanwhile, other teams—maybe even Pete Carroll’s Raiders—could sniff around if they sense uncertainty. If Seattle wants Smith long-term, they need to make their move before that $16 million roster bonus kicks in.

So, will the Seahawks trade Metcalf? Will they extend Geno? The answers aren’t clear yet, but the chaos has already unveiled. One that’s, for sure, have its ripple effect throughout the offseason.