When it comes to NFL injuries, sometimes the cure can be worse than the disease. Just ask JJ McCarthy, the Minnesota Vikings‘ rookie quarterback, who’s gone from potential savior to sideline spectator faster than one can say “Skol.” But according to NFL legend Mark Schlereth, this plot twist has more layers than a Minnesota hotdish.

On Saturday’s episode of the Stinkin’ Truth podcast, Schlereth dropped a bombshell that’s sure to rattle some Viking helmets. He claims McCarthy’s camp pulled a classic end-around on the Vikings’ medical game plan. “I don’t probably think the Vikings did it that way,” Schlereth said, referring to the decision for a full meniscus repair. “I think JJ McCarthy and JJ McCarthy’s people did it that way.”

Initially, the Vikings reported McCarthy would be out for a mere 3-4 weeks, suggesting a quick trim of the torn meniscus. But the script flipped. Schlereth feels McCarthy’s team apparently called an audible, opting for a full repair that sidelines him for the 2024 season.

Schlereth, drawing on his “vast knowledge of being injured and playing on football teams,” believes the Vikings wanted the express lane back to the field. But McCarthy’s squad had other ideas. “JJ McCarthy’s people got a hold of him and said, ‘No, we’re going to repair this so that we don’t have a larger risk of degenerative changes in the knee that are going to cause problems down the road,'” Schlereth explained.

This medical chess move might seem smart for McCarthy’s long-term health, but it’s not without risks. Schlereth consulted his former teammate, now an orthopedic surgeon, who gave odds that would make even the most daring Viking pause. “Meniscus repairs without an ACL being repaired at the same time have about a 30 to 40% chance of healing,” Schlereth revealed. Those aren’t exactly the odds you want when you’re betting on a franchise quarterback.

What went wrong for JJ McCarthy, and what’s next?

The Vikings’ original playbook seemed clear: get McCarthy back on the gridiron pronto. Head coach Kevin O’Connell initially hinted at a short-term absence, suggesting the team was itching to see their rookie sensation back under center. But as they say in Minnesota, “Uff da!” – things didn’t quite go according to plan.

O’Connell, channeling his inner optimist, is now framing this setback as a character-building exercise. “We’ll have a great plan for him, not only in the quarterbacks room… but a process so he and I can continue to build our rapport,” he said on Tuesday. It’s a nice spin, but fans can almost hear the grinding of teeth behind that coach-speak.

This isn’t the first time a team and player have butted heads over injury management (if that even was the case in Minnesota). Remember when Robert Griffin III rushed back from a knee injury in 2013? That didn’t exactly end well for RG3 or the Washington Redskins. On the flip side, Carson Palmer sat out his entire rookie season with the Bengals in 2003 due to a knee injury and went on to have a solid career.

The implications of this decision stretch further than a Dalvin Cook breakaway run. As the Vikings pivot to Plan B – hello, Sam Darnold! – the long-term concerns are as thick as a Minnesota winter. Schlereth warns of a “greater chance of it tearing” with a full repair, especially given the bruising nature of NFL football.

As this medical drama unfolds, Vikings fans are left scratching their horned helmets. Could a quicker return have saved the season? Will this cautious approach pay off in the long run? Only time will tell. But one thing’s for sure: in the NFL, even knee surgeries come with more drama than a Shakespearean play.