Kyle Shanahan Tired of ‘Limited WR’ as Deebo Samuel Could Leave 49ers Instead of Brandon Aiyuk, as Per John Middlekauff

The San Francisco 49ers are caught between a rock and a hard place as they navigate the treacherous waters of roster management. With Super Bowl aspirations on the line, head coach Kyle Shanahan finds himself facing a Sophie’s Choice-esque dilemma – part ways with either Deebo Samuel or Brandon Aiyuk, two generational talents at wide receiver.

Longtime Bay Area reporter Mike Silver stated the team is “actively looking” to deal with Samuel despite no trade materializing on draft night. This came to light after the San Francisco team had been surrounded by talks of earlier letting Brandon Aiyuk get traded to New England. Silver, in the context of this, revealed the Niners are more likely to deal with Deebo Samuel than Brandon Aiyuk, as the Buffalo Bills and New England Patriots continue to show “serious interest” in acquiring one of San Francisco’s star receivers.

The potential word comes amidst growing frustration over Samuel’s perceived limitations as a pure wide receiver, with an inability to consistently separate from defensive backs through precise route running. “I think Kyle Shanahan showed you something drafting that wide receiver (Ricky Pearsall) in the first round,” said former NFL executive John Middlekauff on The Colin Cowherd Podcast. He continued, “Deebo Samuel could not get open this Super Bowl. He can’t run routes. He is limited as a wide receiver, and he can’t get open.”

Considering running routes is one of the main responsibilities of a wide receiver, Middlekauff added, “I think Kyle was tired of [Samuel not being able to get open]. We need to have wide receivers like Aiyuk who can run routes.” While Samuel’s athleticism and versatility are undeniable assets, Aiyuk’s play on the outside provides a unique edge to the team in the presence of the dual threat of Christian McCaffrey. This tug of comparison between the two demands a look at the numbers they put on the board for the 2023 season that saw their team take the Runner-Up position.

The recent season undoubtedly tilts in favor of the 26-year-old receiver, whose numbers are staggeringly better than his counterpart. Yet, Shanahan’s offensive wizardry relies heavily on receivers who can manipulate defensive coverages. Perhaps sensing this disconnect, the 49ers raised eyebrows by using their first-round pick on Florida’s Ricky Pearsall – a high-IQ route technician some scouts feel could render Samuel expendable.

The de­cision to draft Pearsall, known for his remarkable 4.41 40-yard dash time­, has sparked debate. Some­ see him as a precaution in case­ the 49ers part ways with Samuel. Othe­rs view this move as the initial ste­p in dismantling their formidable rece­iving corps. One thing is undeniable: Shanahan is taking a calculate­d risk in a demanding game of roster manage­ment. This could determine­ whether the 49e­rs’ championship aspirations remain viable or face a close­d window.

Will Deebo Samuel’s potential departure ensure a place for Ricky Pearsall?

Ricky Pearsall’s se­lection has sparked excite­ment across the Bay Area. His scouting re­port highlights impressive skills: crisp routes and e­lite hands, suggesting great pote­ntial with him having covered 1547 yards in his NCAA career along with 10 TDs at an average of 15.2. Additionally, Pearsall demonstrates high football IQ and me­ntors younger teammates, signaling a prospe­ct with strong character. However, some­ question whether his athle­ticism alone will translate to NFL success.

Analysts contend that prospects like Georgia’s Ladd McConkey or Texas’ Adonai Mitchell represented better value and potential impact for their pivotal 2024 campaign. The critics argue that Pearsall’s skill set is bested by several wideouts who were still on the board at 31st overall.

Nonetheless, the projected Day 2 pick who was selected by the 49ers after spending premium draft capital evidently highlights being a potential replacement of either Samuel or Aiyuk. “It’s unlikely Pearsall unseats…the team’s slot receiver job in 2024,” cautioned SFGATE’s Eric Ting.

Regardless of how the Pearsall pick ages, one thing is abundantly clear – the 49ers are in championship-or-bust mode. With aging veterans like Trent Williams (set to be 37 in 2025) and George Kittle’s rising cap hits looming, Shanahan and GM John Lynch are leveraging every asset to keep their Super Bowl window cracked open, even if it means parting ways with foundational pieces like the “limited” Samuel.