Russell Wilson’s late-season struggles have Pittsburgh fans doubting the redemption arc bid. Meanwhile, Justin Fields waits in the wings. And it leaves many to wonder. Why not give him a shot? Former NFL QB Dan Orlovsky just turned up the heat with a playful comparison between the two. And it’s sparking serious debates.

Orlovsky shared on X: “QBR this season Justin Fields: 51.1 Russell Wilson: 51.3.” Though the difference is negligible, the implications aren’t. Fields has shown flashes of brilliance this season. On the other hand, Wilson’s late-game blunders and a four-game losing streak have Steelers fans questioning Mike Tomlin’s decisions.

Criticism has been mounting against Tomlin for sticking with Wilson despite his struggles. Russ’s stats for the last four games? He has averaged just 174.5 yards with four touchdowns and two interceptions. His late-game clock management mistakes have drawn sharp rebukes. For example, he failed to get out of bounds in a crucial drive against Cincinnati. “Get out of bounds and save the time,” former Steelers QB Ben Roethlisberger said in his podcast.

On the other hand, Fields boasts a 4-2 starting record and brings a dynamic edge to the Steelers’ offense. He’s showcased his dual-threat abilities in his starts. Fields rushed for 289 yards and five touchdowns with limited opportunities this season. NFL pundits see Fields as a spark plug who could reignite Pittsburgh’s playoff hopes.

The timing is critical for the Steelers. They are entering the playoffs on shaky ground. Questions loom, as they face the red-hot Ravens. Is it time for Fields to take the reins?

A look at the future: Fields or Wilson?

Fields might not be Pittsburgh’s starter, but his potential as an X-factor is undeniable. Former NFL player and analyst Mark Schlereth suggested Fields could be the Steelers’ best chance against Baltimore. “Where they’re at right now, not only not running the ball but taking sacks and putting yourself behind the chains is a problem,” Schlereth said.

“I think the best option is Justin Fields.”

Russell Wilson has taken 12 sacks in the last three games. And this doesn’t bode well against the Ravens’ fierce pass rush. Fields’ mobility could help offset that pressure. Fields has proven he can force defenses to adjust even in limited action this season. Some speculate the Steelers might be holding back Fields to keep his value under wraps as he approaches free agency.

Re-signing him as a starter for 2025 while letting Wilson walk could be part of a larger strategy. Fields, for his part, remains humble but ready. “I’m not sure. We’ll see,” he said when asked about his playoff role. Whether he starts or is used in special packages, his presence alone could shift the balance.

As the playoffs loom, the Steelers face a pivotal decision. Will they stick with Russell Wilson or take a chance on Justin Fields to keep their season alive? Fans are waiting, and the Ravens are watching.