

Could this BE any more suspenseful? Chandler Bing’s iconic F.R.I.E.N.D.S. whine might as well soundtrack the buzz around Pat McAfee’s “Big Night AHT” in Pittsburgh. The ESPN maverick turned WWE wildcard is hosting a sold-out spectacle at PPG Paints Arena—20k seats, live streams, and rumors hotter than a halftime grill-out. But while McAfee’s pitching his Dean Martin-inspired variety show, Steelers Nation’s got one question: Is Aaron Rodgers crashing the party?
Cue Pat McAfee, the Colts’ punter-turned-media-mogul, who teased on Big Ben’s Footbahlin podcast: “The show has so many real moments coming”. Leaning into that signature grin, he added: “I think it’d be a positive reaction… but [we] haven’t spoken.” Translation: Don’t @ me if Kenny Pickett’s still QB1. Yet McAfee insists Rodgers ain’t walking through that arena door—no matter how badly Yinzer Twitter dreams of a black-and-yellow jersey reveal.
Ultimately, McAfee shut down speculation faster than a blitz on third down: “He’s not here. I have not talked to Aaron Rodgers in weeks, months at this point.” Talk about a plot twist. The four-time MVP, freshly cut by the Jets, has been linked to Pittsburgh like Terrible Towels to primetime. But in true football fashion, the real drama’s offstage.
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad
Pat McAfee on Aaron Rodgers: “He’s not here.”
— Nick Farabaugh (@FarabaughFB) April 10, 2025
Rodgers, 40, remains the league’s most tantalizing free agent—a QB with more MVPs (4) than Pittsburgh has Lombardis (6, but who’s counting?). The Steelers, hungry to escape QB purgatory, have reportedly dangled offers. Yet Rodgers’ longtime hype man and podcast partner, swears he’s clueless. “There’s a chance people afterwards go, ‘Freaking didn’t see Aaron Rodgers out there,’” McAfee mused, almost winking through the mic. Cue the conspiracy theories: Is this a Belichick-level smokescreen? Or just McAfee masterminding chaos, WWE-style?
Meanwhile, the Steel City’s buzzing like a Primanti Bros. lunch rush. Imagine Rodgers, fresh off a Jeopardy! gig and a Jets flop, slinging dimes to George Pickens at Acrisure. It’s the stuff of fanfic—until McAfee’s denial hits like a James Harrison sack. Still, hope’s a helluva drug. As Game of Thrones taught us: “The night is dark and full of terrors.” For Steelers fans? More like full of hopium.
Steelers’ QB Quest: Rodgers, Sanders, and the Art of the Audible
Let’s pivot. While McAfee’s playing ringmaster, Pittsburgh’s front office is grinding like it’s Day 3 of the draft. Insider buzz says talks with Rodgers have “positive momentum,” but here’s the kicker: the Steelers are also eyeing Shedeur Sanders, Colorado’s golden-armed heir to Prime Time. It’s a savvy two-minute drill—pressure Rodgers to decide or pivot to youth. Think of it as NFL Darwinism: Adapt or get sacked.
What’s your perspective on:
Is Aaron Rodgers the missing piece for the Steelers, or just another offseason fantasy?
Have an interesting take?
Rodgers, ever the enigma, holds cards tighter than a rookie’s playbook. Post-Jets, he’s floated between Zen retreats and UFO conspiracies, leaving teams to wonder: Does he still wanna play? Signing him is a risk—a $35M gamble on a QB older than Seinfeld reruns. But hey, this is Pittsburgh. They’ve revived legends before (looking at you, Big Ben’s 2018 comeback).
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad

Yet, the Shedeur angle’s spicy. The kid’s got swagger, lineage, and a highlight reel that’d make TikTok blush. Scheduling a visit with him isn’t just due diligence—it’s a power play. “Everything’s either a learn or a win,” McAfee once quipped. For Steelers GM Omar Khan, it’s both: Light a fire under Rodgers and scout the future. Win-win? More like no-lose.
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad
As “Big Night AHT” unfolds—Hulu cameras rolling, A.J. Hawk cracking jokes—the real show’s in the shadows. Rodgers-to-Steelers isn’t dead; it’s in overtime. And McAfee? He’s thriving in the chaos, proving yet again why he’s the NFL’s ultimate disruptor. Whether you’re here for the comedy, the cameos, or the QB carousel, one thing’s clear: “When you see something you want to do, go do the damn thing.”
Mic drop. End zone dance. Let the speculation rage on.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Is Aaron Rodgers the missing piece for the Steelers, or just another offseason fantasy?