“There’s 50 other guys in that locker room who don’t play that position, and those guys don’t care about your three-year plan,” Sports Illustrated’s Albert Breer told Rich Eisen on Thursday, laying bare the stark reality facing Colts head coach Shane Steichen as he benched Anthony Richardson for veteran Joe Flacco.

The decision came after Richardson’s eyebrow-raising admission of fatigue during the Texans game. “I was tired. I ain’t going to lie,” the young quarterback confessed after taking himself out for one play. This moment, though not the sole reason, spotlighted the growing pains of a rookie adjusting to NFL demands.

Stats tell a brutal story of Richardson’s struggles. Through six starts in 2024, he’s posted a league-worst 44.4% completion rate, throwing for 958 yards with four touchdowns against seven interceptions. His 3-3 record masks deeper concerns about his readiness to lead an NFL offense.

Colts HC Steichen’s stance shifted dramatically from his draft-day philosophy. “I think the development of players comes with more experience,” he declared after selecting Richardson fourth overall in 2023. Now, he’s changed his tune: “Joe gives us the best chance to win.” The numbers support this pivot – Flacco has completed 65.7% of his passes for 716 yards, seven touchdowns, and just one interception in limited action.

The situation mirrors what Breer calls “the Trey Lance conundrum” – balancing a raw talent’s need for game reps against the team’s immediate competitive demands. While Richardson watches from the sideline, his teammates chase playoff hopes with the steady hand of a 39-year-old veteran.

The NFL’s development dilemma

The Richardson situation highlights a larger issue plaguing the NFL: the absence of a proper development system for young quarterbacks. “The NFL didn’t want to pay for NFL Europe, that’s it,” Breer explained bluntly to Eisen, pointing to the league’s reluctance to fund its talent pipeline.

College football serves as the NFL’s “golden goose” for player development, but it comes with limitations. College coaches prioritize winning games over preparing players for the pros. This gap leaves rookies like Richardson caught between needing game experience and meeting the NFL’s win-now expectations.

The financial realities make solutions scarce. As Breer noted, football’s infrastructure costs far exceed those of other sports’ developmental leagues. The NFL’s decision to prioritize profits over player development when shuttering NFL Europe continues to impact young quarterbacks today.

Shane Steichen faces this conflict head-on. “I can’t predict the future,” he admitted when asked about Richardson’s return to the starting role. Meanwhile, the coach must balance his promising rookie’s growth against what Breer identifies as his veterans’ immediate career concerns – players who “want to win right now” and secure their own NFL futures.

Speaking of the NFL’s future, want the inside scoop on how the NFL’s global playbook is changing? Head to our channel and dive into this can’t-miss conversation about football’s worldwide future. Catch our latest Think Tank exclusive where Trey Holder sits down with NFL marketing powerhouses Emily and Erin Griffin.