Russell Wilson was hoping for a fresh start with the Pittsburgh Steelers after a disappointing season with the Denver Broncos. The former Super Bowl champion saw the black and gold as an opportunity to further his career. But recent comments from Broncos legend Carl Mecklenburg, who was harshly critical of Wilson, have put those aspirations into a whirlwind of online debates.

While it may not have meant the end of the road for him, it certainly cast a shadow of doubt. Now the Steelers may rethink their strategy, as their $39 million investment in Wilson faces scrutiny due to his leadership abilities on and off the field.

“Russell Wilson isn’t a leader.” The damning words sliced through the NFL world like a hot knife through butter, coming from the mouth of Broncos legend Karl Mecklenburg. In one blistering critique, the Hall of Famer has torched Wilson’s leadership capabilities and exposed what he calls “self-centeredness” that plagued the quarterback’s Denver tenure. 

The explosive comments cast a harsh spotlight on the very qualities once hoped to make Wilson a potential savior for the quarterback-needy Pittsburgh Steelers. These comments by the Hall of Famer made the radio host Doug Gottlieb chime in as well. “The plastic stuff, the unofficial stuff, the coaching, and I know he didn’t have his quarterback coach, the nutritionist, his own workout guy. The extra stuff, you know, where that doesn’t work. Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, it never works when you’re making like a million or two million a year.”

Gottlieb echoed Mecklenburg’s critique, stating, “I think what’s happened is he’s been exposed. These were, you know, issues that and here’s where I feel sympathy for him. I have no doubt that when you switch jobs, you’re trying to kind of figure out how am. I like everyone how everyone says, well I just want to be myself but all right, but you switch jobs. You are a Superbowl champion. There’s a book called The First 90 Days I’ve recommended this several times on different shows with our first 90 days and it’s just basically like what to do when you go to a completely different culture and the idea is your first 90 days you kind of absorb the culture don’t go start doing your own thing.“

Read More: “Salary Cap Fallout”: Denver Broncos Legend Blames Russell Wilson for Justin Simmons Release

Mecklenburg’s critique exposes potential character flaws that could turn off Pittsburgh and any hope Wilson had of joining the Steelers’ storied lineage hangs precariously in the balance

The rise and fall of Russell Wilson in Denver

When the Denver Broncos acquired Russell Wilson, the move was hailed as the final piece to make them contenders. Wilson arrived with a hot resume – Super Bowl winner, 9-time pro bowler, and owner of a newly renewed $245 million contract extension. But after just two seasons, the Broncos released Wilson, admitting their investment was a mistake.

Wilson also had a personal office, which was considered somewhat unconventional back then. Instead of sharing space with his teammates in the locker room, Wilson opted for a separate area. Interim head coach Jerry Rosburg put an end to this arrangement during the last two games of the underwhelming 5-12 season.

“We spoke with Russell Wilson today to inform him of his release after the start of the league year,” general manager George Paton and head coach Sean Payton said in a joint statement. It’s a stunningly rapid fall for the 35-year-old quarterback, who posted records of 7-10 and 4-9 over his two seasons in Denver while failing to reach the playoffs. 

Rather than elevate a roster brimming with talent, Wilson’s inability to put the team first and properly assimilate into the locker room culture torpedoed his Denver tenure. It’s a cautionary tale about the perils of valuing star power over leadership, culture, and team dynamics. The Steelers’ reported interest in Russell Wilson suggests doubts about Kenny Pickett as their franchise QB. Considering the tweets by the Hall of Famer, adding Wilson can be a high-risk, high-reward move that could revitalize them or create turmoil.

Read More: Russell Wilson’s Rumored Move to the Steelers Finds Pat McAfee’s Backing Amidst Hidden Connection: “The Perfect City for Him”