“Envy What the Chiefs Did”: Caleb Williams & JJ McCarthy In for a Rough Ride With Patrick Mahomes’ Luxury Out of Sight Before NFL Draft, Per Insider

The rise of quarterbacks Caleb Williams and JJ McCarthy has been met with both excitement and trepidation as the NFL Draft looms. While their talents are undeniable, the shadow of Patrick Mahomes’ unprecedented success hangs over them, posing a unique challenge in navigating lofty expectations.

The luxury afforded to Mahomes by Chiefs – the ability to learn and develop behind the scenes before bursting onto the national stage – is a privilege these young quarterbacks may not enjoy. As the draft’s top prospects, the spotlight will be intense, with teams and fans eagerly anticipating their immediate impact. Insights from an NFL insider highlight this very contrast, providing a lens into how Williams and McCarthy may have to chart a different path than the one traveled by Mahomes.

John Middlekauff, an NFL insider, directly addressed the contrast between Williams/McCarthy and Mahomes: “I don’t think he [Williams] wouldn’t even start right away… It’s one of those perfect things I think they kind of envy what the Chiefs did years ago to let Patrick Mahomes take a deep breath.” This envious luxury afforded to Mahomes – the ability to patiently develop out of the spotlight – may not be replicated for the top 2024 QB prospects.

Mahomes himself acknowledged the vital role his apprenticeship played, stating “I don’t think it would have happened as fast…I think there would have been a lot more mistakes, especially early in my career.” The Chiefs’ defensive standouts like Derrick Johnson and Justin Houston witnessed Mahomes’ talent up close in practice, with Johnson recalling they were “in awe of what he was doing” even as a rookie.

However, Mahomes could hone his skills gradually, a luxury Williams and McCarthy may be denied as potential franchise saviors expected to produce great results immediately. This measured development path was pivotal for Mahomes, as illustrated by his comments: “Alex [Smith] was way ahead of me at that point where he could run the offense the right way. He was playing so [well] that there was never a thought that I should be playing. I wasn’t supposed to be playing. I was supposed to be learning.”

This is the aspect the podcast also touched upon, with John highlighting to Colin how Caleb and JJ McCarthy are bound to be “thrown into the action.” Yet the teams potentially drafting Williams or McCarthy must balance building a long-term contender versus yielding to fan pressure for instant gratification. This delicate calculus underscores the draft dilemma facing franchises like the Bears – do they draft an elite QB prospect like Williams at #1 overall, or explore trading back to accrue more draft capital to complement their cornerstone player?

Balancing Talent vs. Team Needs

While the prospect of selecting Caleb Williams first overall is enticing, the Bears must carefully weigh the opportunity cost of bypassing additional draft assets. The first pick in the draft remains worth so much. With glaring needs along the defensive line and at offensive skill positions, accumulating more draft capital could allow Chicago to build a more complete roster around their franchise quarterback.

Yet Williams’ prodigious talents are equally difficult to ignore. His combination of arm talent, athleticism, and intangibles have solidified his status atop draft boards. For a franchise starved of consistent quarterback play, Williams could instantly elevate Chicago’s offense alongside players like DJ Moore and Keenan Allen. Swinging a trade may require sacrificing this unique opportunity.

Read More: Bears Mock Draft: Chicago’s Plan B if Something Falls Apart With Caleb Williams & More You Need to Know

Other QB-needy teams like the Raiders and Broncos are also rumored to be exploring trade-up scenarios. Their desperation, combined with the projected depth of this QB class, enhances the Bears’ leverage. However, the higher Williams comes off the board, the less attractive potential trade compensation appears.

Ultimately, this dilemma covers the conundrum faced by decision-makers – do you draft the elite prospect, even at the opportunity cost of neglecting other areas of need? Or do you hedge, trading back to amass more draft capital to hedge against Williams? For the Bears and others, it’s a franchise-altering decision with no clear right answer.

Read More: 2024 NFL Draft: What Does Tom Brady See in J.J. McCarthy?