Here we go again—another Cam Ward vs. Shedeur Sanders showdown. Whether it’s on the CFB battlefield, the Heisman race, or now the NFL Draft, these two always end up being discussed together. Both are chasing that generational talent title, but Ward consistently comes out ahead. Just take a look at the draft odds—Ward is at -100, while Sanders is at -1500, showing a significant gap. However, this competition is no longer just about personal ambition. It now revolves around the Browns’ desperation to secure a quarterback.

Let’s get straight to the point. Myles Garrett almost leaving is what made the Browns’ QB situation—Shedeur or Cam—a real thing. The defensive end didn’t mince words: “The goal was never to go from Cleveland to Canton. It has always been to compete for and win a Super Bowl.” Translation? He’s done being the guy with Hall of Fame numbers and zero wins. You can’t blame him. Unlike Madden Franchise Mode, star players don’t stay just because you want them to. For eight seasons, the Browns have failed to give him a chance to compete for the championship, despite his dominance. Let’s not forget, the Browns haven’t made it to the playoffs for four straight seasons now.

But just like that, all the ‘he’s fed up’ talk went straight to the junk drawer. On Sunday, the Browns stunned everyone with a record-breaking extension for him, a massive NIL-style deal. The numbers? Absurd. A four-year, $160 million extension, with $123.5 million guaranteed, is enough to worry Jerry Jones about Micah Parsons’ contract. In short, Myles Garrett re-signed with Cleveland through 2030 for an astounding $40M per year, leaving the rest of the NFL in awe. But Bleacher Report’s Kristopher Knox is a bit skeptical about Garrett’s sudden shift of heart, saying on X, “I’m also very curious about what changed Myles Garrett’s stance. Money obviously talks, but it feels like the story involves more than just a contract offer he couldn’t refuse.”

Now, here comes the shocking part. NFL draft analyst Moe Moton replied to the same tweet, giving a reason behind Myles Garrett’s decision, saying, “Probably told him, we’re drafting Cam Ward or Shedeur Sanders at 2. Browns players were said to be frustrated with the QB situation last year.” It’s evident that the Browns’ front office never wanted to trade him. It’s clear: Garrett is the cornerstone of the Browns’ D-line identity. But last season’s quarterback situation was the final straw for Garrett. Now that he’s staying put with the Browns, they might search for a suitable quarterback ASAP.

The Browns’ quarterback situation? It’s like a really bad investment, with a ton of cash just sitting there. Deshaun Watson’s time in Cleveland feels more like a $230 million headache than a comeback story. Injuries have kept him off the field, and when he has played, he hasn’t lived up to the hype. Even with the second overall pick, the Browns could grab Cam Ward or Shedeur Sanders, but Watson’s contract is basically a giant anchor they can’t shake.

Instead of taking a hit, though, the Cleveland Browns pulled some salary cap wizardry to free up space. They restructured Watson’s deal, which opens up around $36 million for 2025. This lets them keep Watson while giving them some room to maneuver. So, yeah, there’s a real chance Cam Ward or Shedeur Sanders could end up in Cleveland, even if there are still questions about how much they’d actually change things.

Doubts surround Cam Ward and Shedeur Sanders’ future

The debate rages on—who gets drafted first? But scouts are raising serious questions about whether Sanders and Ward can actually cut it in the pros. Cam Ward, the electric playmaker, extends plays and launches bombs like nobody’s business. He’s a top QB prospect, no doubt. But that gunslinger style comes with risks, and NFL scouts aren’t convinced he can dial it back. An AFC scout, speaking to ESPN’s Jordan Reid, pointed out Ward’s tendency for high-risk plays that don’t always pan out. “He has times where he has to scratch his itch for reckless plays, and it leaves you asking, ‘What the heck was he thinking there?'” the scout said.

The concern isn’t just about a few bad throws—it’s a pattern. “I like him and don’t know if that can be coached out of him.” His unpredictable play cost them last season—that pick-six against Cal, anyone? And his accuracy against Georgia Tech? All over the place. Ward’s got the talent, but teams need to decide if his risky style is a pro-level asset or a liability.

Shedeur Sanders’ draft stock is taking a serious hit. Once a top-6 pick, he’s now sliding down to the 22nd spot. His smooth ride to the NFL has hit some major turbulence. While daily stock fluctuations were expected, teams are now raising concerns about his character. “If you’re not trying to change the franchise or culture, don’t get me.” Bold words, indeed. Some see confidence; others see cockiness. Either way, the buzz is growing: teams are labeling him “arrogant.”

No doubt, being Deion Sanders’ son, Shedeur has always oozed confidence. This was on full display when he dismissed Field Yates’ mock draft, which had him at number 6. Right now, both Sanders and Ward are standing at a crossroads, filled with doubts and speculation.