Is the Kalen DeBoer and Jalen Milroe combo not working as expected? The Alabama quarterback, Milroe, has had a rollercoaster of a season, and his struggles mirror those of his head coach. They started strong, but things took a sudden nosedive. Early in the season, Milroe was a hot topic, appearing prominently in mock NFL drafts and Heisman conversations. However, his recent performances have raised doubts, not just about his future with Alabama but also about his NFL prospects.

On November 24, the CFB Report stirred the pot by posting a picture of Milroe with the question, “Should Jalen Milroe run it back with Alabama next season?” This sparked a wave of criticism from fans who were frustrated with the quarterback’s inconsistency. Many questioned his readiness for the NFL and even his fit within Alabama’s future plans. While his potential remains undeniable, his uneven performances have left fans wondering if he’s the right player for either.

Well, the frustration stems from Milroe’s noticeable decline in performance. Earlier in the season, he was completing over 70% of his passes, but his accuracy dropped to just 55% against the Tennessee Volunteers. Despite this slump, ESPN’s latest mock draft still projects him as a first-round pick, with analyst Matt Miller placing him at No. 28 overall, heading to the Steelers. This ranking, despite his struggles, only fueled more criticism from fans.

Milroe did show flashes of a comeback. Against the Missouri Tigers, he completed around 61% of his passes despite being sacked multiple times. The team rallied for a commanding 34-0 victory. Then came Alabama’s matchup against LSU, where Milroe and the Tide delivered a statement win, blowing out Brian Kelly’s team 42-13. These highs demonstrated what Milroe is capable of, but they’ve been overshadowed by his inconsistent performances in other games. And fans are slamming him again.

Fans are unhappy with Jalen Milroe

The tipping point for many fans was Alabama’s shocking loss to the 6-5 Oklahoma Sooners. Milroe had a nightmare game, completing less than half of his passes, throwing three interceptions, and failing to score a single touchdown. It was a performance that left even his staunchest supporters questioning his future. One CFB fan summed it up by saying, “Yes, he is not ready for the NFL, and he’s already getting paid—what’s the rush?”

Meanwhile, one made a blunt comment saying, “Alabama doesn’t want him back.” And another added to it: “If he wants another college year, he’s got to go someplace else as a Grad Transfer.” Well, let’s not forget Milroe’s accomplishments under Nick Saban from the previous season.

The QB showcased his dual-threat ability, rushing for 600 yards and scoring nine rushing touchdowns while leading Alabama to an SEC championship. He even finished sixth in the Heisman race. However, this season has been a stark contrast, with many fans dubbing him a ‘counterfeit Milroe’ and an ‘imposter’ already. One Texas fan didn’t hold back, writing, “Dear Lord, no. Hell no. NFL or portal to North Texas or something. Hell no, he must go.”

Despite the criticism, Milroe remains projected as a first-round NFL draft pick. Fans have expressed skepticism about this, considering his midseason slump and inconsistent performances. One fan on X commented, “Yes. His draft quality isn’t great rn.”

Still, there’s a glimmer of hope for Milroe supporters. His natural talent and moments of brilliance suggest he has the tools to succeed. A single poor season doesn’t define a career, and there’s always room for improvement. Whether he stays at Alabama, transfers, or declares for the draft, Milroe has the potential to prove his doubters wrong. What’s your take on Milroe’s future? Should he “run it back” with Alabama, transfer, or take his chances in the NFL draft?