The Oklahoma City Thunder were in the middle of their battle against the Indiana Pacers when something felt… off. Isaiah Hartenstein, their towering presence in the paint, was nowhere to be seen as the second half started. Instead of jogging back onto the court, he was heading straight to the locker room. Moments later, the dreaded update arrived—he wasn’t coming back. Just like that, Hartenstein was ruled out with left hip soreness, and now Thunder fans are left wondering what this means moving forward.

Hartenstein had been doing his thing in the first half, logging 14 minutes of solid play—crashing the boards, setting hard screens, and providing that reliable size in the paint. Everything seemed fine, but when the third quarter rolled around, he was nowhere in sight. Kenrich Williams took his spot, and not long after, the Thunder officially shut him down for the rest of the night.

Losing him mid-game is the kind of curveball no one was ready for. The Thunder weren’t dealing with too many surprises before tip-off—Aaron Wiggins was already out with Achilles tendinitis, and Jaylin Williams and Alex Caruso were questionable. But Hartenstein’s abrupt exit? That was unexpected.

Hartenstein just can’t catch a break

If there’s one guy who’s had the worst luck with injuries this season, it’s Hartenstein. It feels like every time he starts getting into a groove, something new pops up. The season didn’t even start before he was sidelined with a left-hand fracture in October. Then January rolled around, and boom—calf strain. Fast forward to March, and it’s been one thing after another. First, a nasal fracture kept him out. Then lower back spasms. And now? Hip soreness.

At this point, it’s like a bad movie where the main character keeps getting hit with plot twists they never saw coming. Just when you think he’s past one hurdle, another one shows up. It’s made it tough for him to stay in rhythm, and the Thunder have had to constantly adjust.

That’s the big question. The tricky thing about hip soreness is that it could mean a lot of different things. Maybe it’s just some minor fatigue, and he’ll be good to go in a game or two. Or maybe it’s something that lingers—muscle irritation, inflammation, or worse, a strain that takes weeks to fully heal.

The Thunder have been careful with their players all season, so don’t be surprised if they play it safe with him. If they list him as day-to-day, that’s the best-case scenario. But if he starts missing multiple games, that’s when it starts getting concerning.

If Hartenstein has to sit out for a bit, the Thunder will need to reshuffle things once again. Kenrich Williams will likely step up, and if Jaylin Williams is healthy, he could see more minutes as well. They’ve dealt with injuries all season and found ways to adapt, but at this point, they’d probably like to catch a break.

With the playoffs creeping closer, every single game matters, and losing a key piece right now isn’t ideal. Now, it’s just a waiting game to see how serious this hip issue is. If Thunder fans have learned anything this season, it’s that nothing ever comes easy—but they’ll be hoping this is just a minor bump in the road and not another frustrating setback for their big man.