A staggering 11.4% drop in viewership hit the NASCAR Talladega Superspeedway race this year, even with Ryan Blaney taking a nail-biting win by a mere 0.012 seconds over Kevin Harvick. As the rubber burned and engines roared, NASCAR’s biggest problem became evident: they’re facing a possible star-power vacuum. The question remains: Are the big racers of yesteryear truly irreplaceable?

Rolling back to yesteryear, NASCAR was once home to household names like Jeff Gordon, Dale Earnhardt Jr., and Jimmie Johnson. As these legends hung up their helmets, the sport’s aura dimmed. ESPN’s Marty Smith, in a spicy interview with “Bringing the Heat,” admits to the dwindling star roster. 

Marty Smith’s Take on the Star-Power Dilemma

The conversation was sparked by FrontStretch’s poignant observation: over the years, NASCAR has bid farewell to legends. The looming question is whether the sport has effectively replaced these titans or if it’s grappling with a star or marketing dilemma. Smith contemplated the query, recalling the era when stars like Tony Stewart, Kevin Harvick, and others were synonymous with NASCAR, their names recognized even by casual sports fans.

Marty Smith stated, “Like people knew these names, peripheral sports fans. I’m not sure how many peripheral sports fans could name 10 NASCAR drivers right now. So, I mean, they can all name Chase. I didn’t name Bill Elliot. There’s another household name. They can all name Chase Elliot right now. But could they name some of the other drivers who are excellent talents? Don’t know.”

“I mean, when we were doing the sport, NASCAR was on Sports Center a minimum of three days a week and typically more than that. So, I mean, that’s, look, I’m sorry, I think that that’s part of it. It’s just like the repetition, you know, almost the kind of habitual consumption. And I just wonder what’s coming.” 

WATCH THIS STORY: NASCAR Kyle Busch Mocks Joe Gibbs With Sarcastic Remark

Smith further added, “Is it going to be another traditional network package? Is it going to be streaming involved? I don’t have any idea. But whoever it is to grow those household names, there’s got to be a lot of promotion, fellows, right? I mean, a lot of promotion.” Recently, NASCAR has seen some ups and downs in viewership during the playoffs. What were the numbers? 

Viewership Rollercoaster in NASCAR vs. Formula 1

Surprisingly, despite its current woes, NASCAR’s recent playoff round in Texas saw a surge in viewership, dwarfing Formula One’s Japanese Grand Prix. Two million on the Comcast-owned USA Network against a mere 479,000 for F1! It’s a glimmer of hope, a flash in the rear-view mirror reminding us of NASCAR’s golden age. Yet, is it enough?

Here’s the twist in our tale: Despite the rollercoaster of viewer statistics, both NASCAR and Formula One find themselves in parallel universes. NASCAR’s hoping to renew its media rights deal, dreaming of the $820 million per year in its current agreement. Formula One, despite forking out big bucks, faces dwindling viewers. Change is the name of the game. But who’ll emerge as the leader of the pack?

READ MORE: Despite Sending Disappointment Across the Community, NASCAR Wins Fans’ Heart With This Masterpiece

2023 marked NASCAR’s 75th lap around the sun, yet the anniversary’s shine hasn’t translated to TV screens. The races might be thrilling, with 14 different winners this season, but the connection to fans seems to be missing a spark plug. The Talladega race had the drama, the adrenaline, and the nail-biting finishes, but not the audience.