The New York Yankees are preparing for the possibility of losing their star player Juan Soto in free agency, which could significantly change their team lineup for the 2025 season. Even though Soto remains their focus following his outstanding performance in 2024, the Yankees are exploring other options in case they can’t keep up with this race for Soto. Among the discussed options is signing veteran Paul Goldschmidt, one of the most consistent basemen in the league.

2022 NL MVP winner Goldschmidt has been known as one of the best hitters in the league. Despite being 37 years old, Paul’s performance this season reflected his strength and reliability. He scored 25 home runs and a respectable .787 OPS for the St. Louis Cardinals; so, the addition of Goldschmidt to the Yankees lineup alongside Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton, and Jazz Chisholm Jr. might elevate them as one of the leading power hitters in the upcoming season.

The Yankees could quest for a fresh start after Soto’s potential exit

As per St. Louis Cardinals Cody Kluge, a BVM journalist said, “New York’s lineup should have some pop again in 2025 with Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton, Jazz Chisholm Jr., and others. Adding Goldschmidt to that mix could make the Yankees the top power-hitting team in the majors for a second straight year.” With Anthony Rizzo expected to leave via agency, the Yankees will require a consistent hitter to fill the gap at first base. Although players like Pete Alonso and Christian Walker are options, they also come with a higher cost and greater uncertainty.

So, opting for Paul Goldschmidt presents an alternative without compromising on power or team leadership qualities, which aligns perfectly with the Yankees’ immediate requirements. Moreover, adding Goldschmidt to the Yankees team will not just strengthen the base spot but also enhance an already strong lineup. His skills for performing under pressure could be the game changer as they strive to remain competitive in an AL East division and target a championship win in 2025. With free agency picking up steam, having Paul Goldschmidt as an option might just be what the Yankees need to maintain their aspirations of winning a title.

Teams lining up in the bidding war for Paul Goldschmidt

With his 2024 free agency, Paul Goldschmidt has caught the attention of several teams, one of them being the Milwaukee Brewers. They see Goldschmidt as an improvement at first base, especially if the team decides to part ways with Rhys Hoskins. Milwaukee appreciates his experience and leadership qualities along with his contributions, despite a dip in recent performance. So, Goldschmidt’s reasonable price tag in comparison to players in hype makes him an attractive choice.

Another possible spot for Paul is the San Francisco Giants, who could use him to stabilize their offense and defense at first base. The Arizona Diamondbacks are also seen as a potential suitor, with a reunion offering the dual benefit of fan appeal and veteran experience to complement their young core. Additionally, the Philadelphia Phillies are monitoring the situation, viewing Goldschmidt as a fallback option if they fail to address other key roster needs this offseason.

For Paul Goldschmidt, the decision will likely hinge on his priorities—whether he seeks a shot at another World Series title, a return to a familiar market, or the chance to mentor young talent. His ability to adapt and contribute offensively and defensively will keep him in demand, making his next destination a pivotal factor for whichever team secures his signature.