Recently, the New York Yankees acquired Jazz Chisholm Jr. from the Miami Marlins in a highly publicized trade. “It was super exciting,” Jazz Chisholm said, but there were a few “errors.” The goal was to strengthen their infield and improve their lineup by adding a dynamic player with 30/30 potential. Gleyber Torres has had defensive struggles, so the choice to keep him on has come under substantial criticism.

Moreover, the Yankees were under scrutiny for attempting to address Torres’ defensive shortcomings and keeping him on the team even after Chisholm arrived. Gary Sheffield Jr., an MLB analyst, voiced his annoyance on X. Sheffield criticized Torres for his subpar defensive play and asked why the Yankees kept him when they could have acquired Chisholm. Now, people are engaged in an energetic debate over this circumstance.

MLB analyst blasts infield “positions” of  Yankees

When speaking about the Yankees’ approach to Gleyber Torres, Gary Sheffield Jr. didn’t hold back. Despite leading both leagues in “errors” made at second base, he brought attention to Torres’ decision to switch positions in a tweet. “The Yankees playing Jazz Chisholm at third base tonight because their second baseman refuses to move positions, who happens to lead both leagues in errors at the position. In a contract year he’s doing this. His level of comfort within the organization should be studied,” Sheffield stated.

The Yankees are having trouble balancing their infield, which is the reason for this criticism. Despite his consistency, Gleyber Torres has been a mess at second base. Among MLB second basemen, he has committed the most mistakes with 13 this season. His future with the team is now under scrutiny due to this, particularly in light of the addition of Chisholm, who might offer a much-needed defensive upgrade.

Chisholm’s signing was viewed as an attempt to bolster the Yankees’ infield. Chisholm’s quickness has been shown when playing second base and center field. But because Gleyber Torres is adamant about staying at second base, his position with the Yankees is still unclear. Since Chisholm hasn’t played third base professionally, there have been rumors that he might do so. However, Torres’s response was alarming regarding the spots.

Gleyber Torres’ ‘comfort’ thoughts on the current situation

Fuel to the fire has been added to the debate by Gleyber Torres’ response to the prospect of switching positions. Torres made it apparent which spot he preferred when questioned about the possible transfer to third base. Torres stated, “I don’t like it,” following a recent game. “I’m a second baseman. I play second.” This denial hits hard.

Torres’ refusal to give up his favored stance appears in this statement. He did concede, though, that he would be prepared to play third base if the team required him to. He declared, “Everything is on the table.” Torres’ unwillingness to switch positions is alarming particularly given his defensive shortcomings. His outlook toward the switch could have a big impact on how well he adjusts and plays third base. His uncertainty could impede his ability to adjust to a new position, which is where a player’s mentality comes into play.

The Yankees’ infield setup presents a problem right now. At second base, there is a logjam due to Chisholm’s arrival. Torres has led all second basemen in mistakes since 2018, thus the team has to determine whether to transfer him to third base or find another way. The Yankees’ overall success and defensive steadiness depend on this choice. Thus, it is on them to devise a play-by-play infield arrangement that takes advantage of Chisholm’s skills and takes care of Torres’ defensive shortcomings.

At present, the Yankees’ hope of making the playoffs will be impacted by the outcome of this infield challenge. What are your thoughts on this? Share your take in the comments below.