This week marks the conclusion of the 2024 World Series in Los Angeles, with New York Yankees fans once again seeing their hopes fade. Despite a star-studded roster and one of their best performances in years, the Yankees couldn’t prevail against the National League champions, the Los Angeles Dodgers. After reaching the World Series for the first time since their victory in 2009, the Yanks ultimately fell short against Shohei Ohtani and his team. Going into the weekend, the Yankees were already in a do-or-die situation, trailing 3-0 as the Dodgers held a commanding lead.

This loss may be somewhat acceptable for the Yankees organization, but it’s much harder for New York fans to digest. Recently, fans have expressed their disappointment, particularly after the MLB-affiliated X page ‘Talkin’ Yanks’ highlighted a disturbing statistic. The tweet read: “Since 2013, the Yankees are 6-0 in playoff series against AL Central teams and 0-6 in series against all other postseason opponents. Record-wise, the Yankees are 19-6 against AL Central teams and 10-24 against other postseason opponents during that span.”

This statistic has struck a nerve with the New York Yankees’ fans, who are frustrated watching their legendary team fall to a less financially dominant Dodgers squad. Many fans have voiced their frustrations, some even calling for changes within the team, starting with General Manager Brian Cashman and Manager Aaron Boone.

New York Yankees’ fans direct frustration toward Brian Cashman and Aaron Boone

Cashman, who started from scratch with the New York Yankees, has been a part of the organization for over two decades. Under his leadership, the Yankees claimed seven American League pennants and four World Series championships. However, despite his past achievements, fans are now voicing frustration with the team’s recent lackluster performance since their last championship win in 2009. One fan highlighted this discontent, demanding, “The Curse of Cashman is now 15 years old. Firing him would address both managerial and personnel issues.”

Another fan echoed this sentiment, pointing out the team’s American League dominance yet postseason struggles by saying, “AL Central dominance, but postseason struggles.” Supporters are also targeting manager Aaron Boone, who transitioned from his career as a former infielder and TV analyst to managing the Yankees in 2018. One user, disappointed with Boone’s tenure, commented, “Sounds like we should fire Aaron Boone.” Another commenter added, “Fire Cashman, Fire Boone, Re-sign Soto, Take the C off Aaron Judge’s jersey, Reload,” expressing the growing calls for change within the New York Yankees’ leadership.

The outrage didn’t stop there. As fans scrolled through social media, more voiced their anger over the Yankees’ high payroll, which, according to FoxSports.com, stands at around $309.4 million — the highest payroll for any team falling short in the World Series. One fan criticized the team’s spending and Boone’s and Cashman’s performance, saying, “$300 million payroll, and we still can’t get consistent contact and situational hitting throughout the lineup. It’s a disgrace. We’re too top-heavy, as usual. Once again, Cashman and Boone have failed this organization. When are they going to learn?”

With next year’s payroll estimated at around $239.4 million (including Juan Soto and Gleyber Torres), fans are left questioning how effectively these resources are being managed. Currently, the spotlight is on the New York Yankees’ management. How do you feel about fans demanding changes? Is letting go of Aaron Boone and Brian Cashman the best solution to turn around the team’s performance? Share your opinion below.