The New York Mets bagged Juan Soto in the biggest offseason trade in the MLB, and they are not backing down. On January 25, owner Steve Cohen affirmed the Mets’ dismissal of reuniting with Pete Alonso at the Amazin’ Day event, given the 30-year-old declined their prior offer of a seven-year, $158 million deal. And now, the team is eyeing another star player: Eight-time All-Star Platinum Glover, Nolan Arenado.

While Soto’s inclusion has already boosted the Mets’ lineup, adding a player of Nolan’s caliber would further push their chances of a title. After all, Arenado is regarded as one of the best third basemen in the league—he donned the St. Louis Cardinals last season; his powerful bat combined with his Gold Glove defense would solidify the infield and free up resources for other areas of need. However, there is a certain hurdle for acquiring Arenado: his contract terms.

Nolan Arenado is owed approximately $74 million over the next three seasons, which might alarm other teams but not the Mets. But under Cohen’s strategic leadership, the Mets’ financial flexibility allows them to secure him comfortably. On the other hand, the Cardinals would be willing to trade him after a disappointing 2024 season; the team is now looking forward to moving Arenado’s contract in exchange for young prospects and future assets.

As for the Mets, their potential pursuit of Arenado is not just about upgrading the roster. Acquiring Nolan can help them go all in for winning; moreover, it marks a clear response to the uncertainties around Pete Alonso’s signing, easing the sting caused by the fallout. So, while the Mets’ offseason strategy is transforming into a strategic move, acquiring Nolan Arenado could bring a host of other benefits for the team.

How can Nolan Arenado’s addition shape the Mets’ future?

While the potential deal of Nolan Arenado to the New York Mets may not be official yet, the idea of adding the league’s one of the best third basemen seems interesting. If the New York Mets were to pull the trigger on this deal, it could have a major impact on their roster, providing both immediate and long-term benefits. However, this deal might prove to be a double-edged sword for the Mets.

The most obvious positive would be the upgrade; their current third baseman Brett Baty’s struggle at the position has been a concerning situation for the New York Mets. Adding Arenado would instantly pave the way for a dynamic defensive duo, as he will pair with Francisco Lindor at shortstop. This improvement on defense could make a world of difference, especially in close games where run prevention becomes critical.

On top of that, if Nolan Arenado could move to the corner of infield, that would mean Mark Vientos moves to first base, improving their overall defensive depth However, while Arenado’s prowess would significantly help the Mets, the question of his offensive output remains a key factor. Coming off the worst season he ever had since his rookie season seems to be an alarming situation, but if Arenado steps up and regains his form, it would mean a powerful complement to the Mets’ current lineup.

Even if the numbers show a decline, his experience and leadership can be beneficial for the Mets. However, the financial commitment and potential decline in his production are factors that need to be weighed carefully. If the Mets are willing to take on the risk of his contract and invest in his bounce-back potential, the rewards could be substantial.