Sean Casey: A Favorite Among Yankees Vets, but a ‘Disconnect’ That Marked the End of His Stint as Hitting Coach

MLB veteran Sean Casey recently announced that he will not be continuing with the New York Yankees as their hitting coach for the 2024 season. This marks the end of his 2-month trial run with the team, which reportedly didn’t bring in any impactful results, with the team’s veterans like Aaron Judge and DJ LeMahieu struggling all the same. But the rookies had to face the worst of it.

Casey’s coaching style differed vastly from what the minor league taught the Yankees. It created a disconnect between the prior lessons and what the players had to follow now. But what was the actual reason that made Casey leave the Yanks?

Uncovering the Real Reason Behind Sean Casey’s Departure From the New York Yankees

2023 has been a difficult year for the Yankees. The team had a year-old unchanged roster, poor defense, and a lack of individual focus on the rookies’ forms. The Yankees hired ex-MLB analyst Casey, famous for his ability to form connections with the players, on the 10th of July during this season’s All-Star break. He replaced Dillon Lawson, whose training methods were mostly effective for anything but baseball. Casey revealed in his recent podcast that he and New York Yankees manager Aaron Boone discussed his return for the 2024 season.

Casey turned Boone down, stating ‘family reasons’ as a cause for the exit. “I’m not gonna be able to come back next year because I have my two daughters at home,” Casey explained. “I think getting divorced a few years ago — I have those girls 50 percent of the time. I just can’t imagine being away for eight months.”. Did he really leave the team in worse shape than when he met them for that reason?

In the minor leagues, Lawson focused on heavy analytics and hard hits. Former prospect Ben Ruta revealed in an interview that the minor league training included strange practices, stating, “There’s no baseball being taught”. One of the many instances included a bizarre game. The players had to hit or throw a ball at a minimum of 95+ mph to score a point in their spring training practice game called “pitcher vs. hitters”.

Casey was famous for his all-inclusive coaching philosophy, which was vastly different from that of Lawson. He adapted a strategic training approach, focusing on a player’s mental performance as well as the physical one. Brian Cashman and Boone’s support backed him in bringing a revolution to their form on the field. A revolution that failed to happen.

A Drastic Downfall of New York Yankees Under Casey’s Charge

The team saw a decline in their form after Casey’s induction as a hitting coach. Their offense, in particular, took a serious hit, going down to .221/.307/.381 .221/.307/.381 from .231/.301/.410, with the average run per game declining to 3.8 from the previous 4.4. Rookies like Anthony Volpe, Everson Pereira, and Oswald Peraza gave lackluster performances in the second half of the season. Reasons included not getting enough rest and failure to focus on their individual weaknesses.

Read More: 19 years After Handing ALCS Humiliation to Derek Jeter, Red Sox’ David Ortiz Brutally Mocks Yankees Legend on Live TV

Veterans who openly supported Casey’s tactics, like Aaron Judge and DJ LeMahieu, were overlooked, especially after their injuries caused a major effect on the Yankees’ 2023 downfall as a result of the team’s decision to stick with several injury-prone players. The disconnect caused by multiple training methods was the main reason for their decline this season.

Casey won’t be back as an MLB coach anytime soon. But we can hope that he brings some changes to his methods, should he get back on the field again.

Watch This Story: Yankees Prep For 2024 Season After Disastrous Year, But Releasing This Star Raises Concerns