
USA Today via Reuters
Oct 31, 2021; Atlanta, Georgia, USA; Houston Astros second baseman Jose Altuve (27) reacts to striking out against the Atlanta Braves during the fifth inning of game five of the 2021 World Series at Truist Park. Mandatory Credit: Brett Davis-USA TODAY Sports

USA Today via Reuters
Oct 31, 2021; Atlanta, Georgia, USA; Houston Astros second baseman Jose Altuve (27) reacts to striking out against the Atlanta Braves during the fifth inning of game five of the 2021 World Series at Truist Park. Mandatory Credit: Brett Davis-USA TODAY Sports
The move to left field for Jose Altuve hasn’t exactly been smooth sailing, and critics were quick to pounce after he mishandled two routine skyballs last week. The question on everyone’s mind: Can a veteran second baseman really make the transition to left field at 35 years old? Despite rising criticism, MLB Analyst Ken Rosenthal is standing firmly behind the Houston Astros’ decision.
Rosenthal, speaking in Foul Territory, expressed confidence in Altuve’s ability to adapt. “They’re looking for him to simply handle the position,” he said, underscoring the fact that they aren’t expecting any Gold Glove-caliber performance. Instead, the Astros are hoping for competent, steady defense from their star second baseman-turned-left fielder. “The fact that he is so into it and so energized, that to me is like, yeah, it’s the right thing to do.”
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad
“We’re looking for him to simply handle the position.”@Ken_Rosenthal says Jose Altuve is savvy enough to play a competent left field in time. pic.twitter.com/5lQdwiHlyF
— Foul Territory (@FoulTerritoryTV) March 20, 2025
Despite the mishaps, Rosenthal points to Altuve’s experience and veteran savvy as key assets in overcoming any early defensive struggles. “You can make a case that he has struggled defensively for several years now, and it hasn’t really carried over much,” Rosenthal noted. Even though there are some defensive setbacks, Altuve has always remained an elite hitter.
The real question now is: how will Altuve handle the pressure moving forward?
While the mistakes on defense have been frustrating for fans, Rosenthal’s confidence in the Astros’ decision suggests that the organization believes in their star veteran’s ability to adapt. As the season progresses, fans and analysts alike will be watching to see if Altuve can indeed rise to the challenge and prove to the doubters that his future on the left is quite brighter than they believed!
What’s your perspective on:
Can Jose Altuve silence his critics and master left field at this stage of his career?
Have an interesting take?
Jose Altuve vows redemption after costly errors in training
It’s not every day you see a former MVP scrutinized for his position change. But that’s exactly the situation Jose Altuve is finding himself in this spring. The newly shifted left fielder whose change in position is causing a stir finds himself in a pool of skepticism.

ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad
After all, few expect a player of his caliber to stumble, especially after so many years of dominance. Yet, two glaring errors in as many days have some wondering if the veteran can handle the outfield switch. However Altuve isn’t one to back down so easily. “I’ve been in tough situations before and I overcame that,” he said in his post-game interview.
“I’m ready to go out there and play good left field. I’m going to keep working hard and be a great left-fielder.” His words show his unwavering self-belief, but can his confidence translate into the field?
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad
The scrutiny surrounding his transition to left field is understandable. It’s a high-stakes move, especially for a team like Houston Astros with championship aspirations, and mistakes like these only add fuel to the fire. Fans are anxiously watching, and the pressure on Altuve is undeniable. He knows the stakes, and with his track record of bouncing back from adversity, there’s hope he can turn this situation around.
Have something to say?
Let the world know your perspective.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Debate
Can Jose Altuve silence his critics and master left field at this stage of his career?