Pete Alonso’s offseason has been, well, kind of awkward. After turning down a pretty generous offer last month, he’s been stuck in free agency limbo for weeks. For a guy who’s been a consistent slugger, you’d think teams would be lining up—but nope, it’s been radio silence. Was passing on that deal a gutsy call or a swing-and-miss? Either way, the clock’s ticking, and Mets fans are watching closely.

As for the Mets, they’re not exactly rolling out the red carpet yet. Sure, Alonso has the history, but he’s not getting any younger, and a long-term deal could cost them big. Enter Alex Bregman—the younger, more versatile option who’s also on their radar. Insiders say Alonso could still end up back in Queens if the Mets decide he’s worth it, but don’t count on this being a quick decision. Could the Mets pull off the bold move of landing both? For now, it’s a waiting game.

Pete Alonso’s sweepstakes shrink rapidly at present

Alex Bregman and the Astros look like they’re heading for Splitsville, thanks to a reported $50 million gap in contract talks. And while the Mets could be tempted to swoop in, Pete Alonso is still hanging out at the top of the free-agent first baseman list—though the market is awfully quiet. Seven weeks after turning down a big offer, he’s still searching for a new home. Metsmerized Online noted on X, “The entire industry believes [the Mets] are going to re-sign Pete Alonso.” Meanwhile, the Red Sox might be eyeing Bregman, making things a bit more interesting.

The Mets already caused a splash by locking in Juan Soto with a record-breaking 15-year, $765 million deal. Imagine adding Pete Alonso back into that mix—the Mets’ lineup would be downright terrifying. It could be the dream combo to finally break their championship drought since 1986. Plus, if Alonso plays his cards right, a shorter deal with the Mets could set him up nicely for another free-agency run in 2026 or 2027. Oh, and don’t count the Yankees out of the mix just yet—they’ve been sniffing around Alonso, too.

Are the New York Yankees keen to have Pete Alonso on their team?

There’s been plenty of chatter about the New York Yankees possibly adding Pete Alonso to their roster, but the reality is a bit murky on that one. While some reports suggest the Yankees are eyeing him, other sources claim the team has “zero interest” in signing the slugger.

The Yankees have already made some significant offseason moves, including signing Max Fried and trading for Cody Bellinger and Devin Williams, which has added depth and flexibility to their roster. With players like Bellinger and Jazz Chisholm capable of playing multiple positions, first base might not even be a priority for them right now. So, while Alonso’s name has been in the mix, the Yankees’ cautious approach and preference for short-term deals leave his potential move to the Bronx far from a sure thing.

Paul’s signing has been a significant addition to the team. They would be able to shift Jazz Chisholm Jr. from the third base to his usual second base position. Furthermore, the presence of Anthony Volpe strengthens the infield, which could be a great move for the 2024 American League Championships. Speculations are high among the fans about a probable signing of Nolan Arenado, who is a former teammate of Paul.

The New York Yankees’ Goldschmidt signing has created a probable chance of getting Arenado on board. Paul and Nolan are very close friends, and thus, the signing might have a significant influence on Nolan. He might be interested in closing off the no-trade clause and moving into the free agency market. However, the Yankees have not yet made an official statement about it. And even a top MLB Insider, Jack Curry, denied any chances of Arenado donning the Yankees jersey next. So, does Pete fit into the team’s plans just yet? Guess we’ll find out!