The New York Mets have a choice ahead as they review their team composition and financial plans for the future. Pete Alonso is looking for a contract extension as he continues to make his mark as a power hitter for the team. However, sources suggest there is a possibility that the franchise might see value in switching focus to Alex Bregman instead – an agile and multifaceted star player from the Houston Astros who will become a free agent after 2024. This potential change in direction could significantly alter the Mets’ lineup while also addressing concerns regarding aging players and positional effectiveness.

Alonso burst onto the scene in 2019 as a hitter in baseball with a record of 192 home runs in the last five seasons alone. However, questions about his defensive skills and athleticism have arisen, which might make it risky to invest over $200 million in him. Historically, players reliant on raw power without defensive contributions age poorly, with declining performance becoming an issue by their early 30s.

Will the Mets prioritize Alex Bregman over Alonso?

Metsmerized Online posted a clip from the Fair Territory podcast with Ken Rosenthal in which he commented on Alex Bregman’s market and if the Mets hold any chance at him. “Arenado is not the player that Bregman is right now. He’s also three years older, but Bregman is going to cost considerably more.”, he said, continuing, “Now the Mets are interesting because the entire industry believes they’re going to re-sign Pete Alonso, but if you’re the Mets and you’re going to commit that kind of money – whatever the number comes out to be with Alonso – maybe you’d rather pay Alex Bregman and then move Vientos to first.”

He further adds that the Mets may prefer Bregman for his athletic background as compared to Alonso’s. He expects the Mets to consider these quests with Scott Boras while he makes his final guess to Alonso.

A restructured Mets roster could maximize internal resources by moving Mark Vientos to first base. Vientos, a natural power hitter, could transition smoothly to the position while filling Alonso’s offensive void. This would free up funds to pursue Bregman, who not only addresses a need at third base but also provides leadership and versatility that align with the Mets’ goal of sustained success.

From a financial perspective, the Mets have the resources to explore bold strategies under owner Steve Cohen. Allocating $200 million to Bregman instead of Alonso would diversify the roster’s skill set and protect against the pitfalls of investing heavily in a one-dimensional player. Additionally, Bregman’s athleticism makes him a safer long-term bet, ensuring his contract retains value throughout its duration.

Choosing Bregman over Alonso would signify a new direction for the Mets—one focused on balance, versatility, and sustained competitiveness. While Alonso has been a fan favorite and offensive powerhouse, the time may have come for the Mets to prioritize a broader, more athletic vision for their future.

The Case Against a $200 Million Deal for Pete Alonso

Pete Alonso’s power is undeniable—192 home runs since his debut in 2019, leading all MLB hitters during that span. But his profile raises red flags for a long-term contract. Alonso’s value depends almost entirely on his offense. He ranks below average defensively at first base, with a -6 Outs Above Average in 2023. Committing over $200 million to a player with limited athleticism risks locking the Mets into a one-dimensional investment that could decline quickly as he ages.

First basemen reliant on power often see steep drop-offs in production. From Albert Pujols to Chris Davis, examples of heavy contracts for power-first players ending poorly are numerous. Alonso’s limited speed and lack of defensive versatility make it harder to offset a potential offensive decline. If his home run production falters in his 30s, his contract could become a major burden for a Mets team aiming for sustained competitiveness.

Shifting focus from Pete Alonso to Alex Bregman represents a forward-thinking approach for the Mets. By prioritizing athleticism and versatility, the team can avoid the risks tied to Alonso’s declining profile and secure a more balanced, sustainable roster. This move could signal a bold new era for the franchise.