Eyeing Aaron Judge’s Longevity, Could a First Base Switch Be on the Cards Eventually?

Aaron Judge’s power and presence are synonymous with those of the modern New York Yankees. The Captain’s record-breaking feats and relentless drive have solidified his place among the legends. However, injuries are a constant shadow, a testament to the relentless physical toll of playing the outfield. As a new era dawns in the Bronx, marked by a dramatically transformed outfield, whispers of a seismic shift grow louder.

Could Judge follow the path of another superstar, Bryce Harper, and transition to the less physically taxing position of first base? Might this change be the key to extending his dominance and etching his name even deeper into the annals of baseball history?

The Aaron Judge factor

The All-Rise’s impact on the Yankees is undeniable. Since his 2016 debut, he’s carved a legacy that would make Yankee legends blush. Five All-Star selections, three Silver Slugger awards, an AL MVP title in 2022, and the prestigious crown of setting the single-season home run record in the American League—Judge’s resume is a testament to his raw talent and dedication. The Captain has become a fan favorite, a symbol of hope, and the cornerstone of the franchise. However, the road hasn’t been without its bumps.

Injuries, including a recent oblique strain, lingering toe issues, and a history of wrist and shoulder problems, highlight the need for careful management of Judge’s powerful physique. A potential position change could be key to ensuring his long-term success. Furthermore, a rapidly evolving outfield landscape could also play a major role in dictating Judge’s future position.

Shifting outfield dynamics for Aaron Judge

The Yankees of 2024 look dramatically different from seasons past, especially in the outfield. The blockbuster acquisition of Juan Soto, a generational talent and one of the best hitters in baseball, was a statement of intent. But it wasn’t the only move.

The additions of Alex Verdugo, an above-average hitter from the Boston Red Sox, and Trent Grisham, a two-time Gold Glove Award winner, solidified an already impressive outfield. Throw in Giancarlo Stanton’s increasing utility as a part-time corner outfielder, and it’s clear that there’s a logjam of talent eager for their time under the bright lights.

This dynamic shift brings both opportunity and complications for the Yankees. How does their captain, Aaron Judge, fit into the new landscape? The rise of young stars and looming contractual uncertainties could also reshape the Yankees’ long-term outfield strategy.

The next generation

Two names stand out as potential heirs to the outfield throne: Spencer Jones and Jasson Dominguez. Jones, the Yankees/top prospect, is a towering powerhouse often compared to a left-handed Aaron Judge. He possesses raw power and surprising speed, making him a true force to be reckoned with. MLB Pipeline’s Top 100 Prospects list ranks him 84th overall, signaling a player on the verge of stardom. Then there’s Dominguez, affectionately known as “The Martian.”

The young slugger has already made his mark with a thrilling, albeit brief, stint in the majors last year. Despite recovering from Tommy John surgery, Dominguez, ranked 41st on MLB Pipeline’s Top 100 list, is poised to be a major contributor in the near future with his switch-hitting prowess and raw talent. Another major wildcard in the Yankees’ outfield equation is superstar Juan Soto.

Acquired in a blockbuster trade, Soto’s contract expires after the 2024 season. If he departs via free agency, it would create a natural slot in the outfield, likely preserving Judge’s current position for the foreseeable future. However, if the Yankees manage to re-sign Soto—potentially with a historic long-term contract—the need to reposition Aaron Judge to first base becomes even more urgent.

Extending a legacy

While Aaron Judge has primarily been an outfielder throughout his career, the physical demands of the position could take a toll as he ages. This is where first base presents a tempting alternative. It’s a less physically taxing position that could significantly extend his playing career while mitigating the risk of further injuries. Notably, this isn’t Judge’s first foray into the possibility of an infield play.

Beyond his college first base experience in Fresno State, Judge’s recent offseason reps at the position suggest flexibility for the future. Could this initial experiment evolve into a long-term solution?

Read More: New York Yankees Captain Aaron Judge Sparks Twitter War With an Unusual Move in Spring Training: “Preparing For That Move in 6 Years”

The Yankees might benefit immensely from keeping their captain’s legendary bat in the lineup while better managing his health. This potential transition isn’t without precedent; another superstar outfielder in MLB, Bryce Harper, made a similar switch to first base. Could Harper’s experience offer a glimpse into what the future holds for Aaron Judge?

Will Judge go the Harper route? 

Bryce Harper’s trajectory offers a potential roadmap. In 2019, he signed a massive 13-year deal with the Philadelphia Phillies, primarily as an outfielder. However, after undergoing Tommy John surgery in November 2022, Harper shifted to first base in 2023 to protect his arm. It remains to be seen how successful this transition will be over the long haul, but it certainly underscores the potential for Judge to follow suit.

The exact timing of Judge’s possible switch remains unpredictable, dependent on several factors. If their current first baseman, Anthony Rizzo, leaves in free agency, an immediate opening at first base could arise. The Bombers might also choose to ease Judge into the position gradually, giving him reps during the season as a strategic way to manage his workload. For now, it certainly looks like the Yankees face a delicate balancing act.

Balancing act for the Yankees

On one hand, maximizing Judge’s impact on the franchise is paramount, and switching positions might be the best way to do so. On the other hand, maintaining elite production in the outfield is crucial, especially considering the team’s recent acquisitions of Soto, Verdugo, and Grisham. The rise of young prospects like Jones and Dominguez further complicates the equation. For now, the question of Judge’s eventual move to first base hinges on a complex interplay of factors.

Read More: Aaron Judge Set to Play New Position? Yankees Captain Ready for Any Role Following 2023 Injury Concerns

The Yankees must prioritize his health while optimizing his offensive contributions within the team’s overall outfield strategy. While not a certainty in the immediate future, a strategic shift to first base could be a prudent long-term solution to maximize Aaron Judge’s potential and write new chapters in his illustrious career with the New York Yankees.