MLB Payrolls: All Teams Except Five Cut Their Roster Budget

Heading into the 2025 MLB season, only five teams are standing out with increased payrolls. With 25 others cutting back on spending, the Phillies, coming off a strong postseason campaign, have increased their payroll by $34.6 million, the league’s highest. Meanwhile, the Orioles have also upped their budget by $30.5 million in a departure from their approach to spending. In stark contrast, the New York Yankees and New York Mets—often synonymous with extravagant payrolls—adopted a different approach.

The Yankees cut $24.5 million while signing top free agent Max Fried to bolster their rotation, while the Mets slashed a league-leading $78 million despite acquiring superstar Juan Soto in a blockbuster deal. This strategic approach contrasts sharply with past off-seasons, where these teams consistently broke spending records, often with little regard for financial restraint. Brooks Gate posted a list of 2025 MLB payrolls, comparing it to that of last season. Additionally, the analysis highlighted teams that have significantly downsized their payrolls, such as the Braves, the White Sox, and a surprising contender, the Mets.

The Phillies’ spending surge aligns with their championship aspirations after consecutive postseason appearances; they’ve prioritized retaining key players while adding talent to build on their NL dominance. The Orioles, long criticized for their frugality, now appear committed to sustaining their young core’s success by bolstering their roster with proven veterans. This aggressive strategy represents a stark departure from their low-budget operations during the rebuilding years.

However, several contenders tightened their belts. The Atlanta Braves, despite leading many games in MLB last season, trimmed their payroll by $71.1 million, prioritizing internal development and cost-effective deals. The Los Angeles Dodgers, fresh off a World Series title, maintained their payroll near $353 million but avoided major new commitments, relying on existing depth and smart acquisitions like KBO infielder Hyeseong Kim. These moves reflect a growing league-wide trend toward balancing spending with sustainability, which now invites a critical question.

Does spending more guarantee success in MLB?

The relationship between payroll size and success on the field is far from straightforward. Teams such as the Los Angeles Dodgers have frequently been at the top in terms of salaries and clinched the 2024 World Series victory. However, splurging on players doesn’t ensure a championship win every time. The Mets held the payroll large in 2023, stumbled, and failed to make it to the playoffs, proving that just pouring money into a team doesn’t always lead to success on the field.

On the other hand, clubs such as the Tampa Bay Rays and the Baltimore Orioles have managed to stay competitive at high levels by prioritizing player growth and effective team management while working with modest finances. So, in today’s Major League Baseball, success hinges on how teams manage their resources rather than on spending power alone, as exemplified by successful franchises like the Dodgers and the Rangers leveraging robust development programs and strategic player acquisitions alongside depth in their rosters.

While smaller budget teams have capitalized on analytics and shrewd roster decisions to gain an edge over richer adversaries, in the end, with significant payroll disparities and diverse approaches, the 2025 season promises to test whether aggressive spending or strategic restraint yields better results. What’s your take on this? Let us know below.