Pete Alonso’s power has long been the Mets’ calling card. However, in 2024, José Iglesias quietly had the better season. His capability to get on base, make continuous contact and provide defensive flexibility gave him an edge. While Alonso’s home runs often stole the spotlight, Iglesias’ steady production made larger effects across 162 games.

So, now, the Mets is in a dilemma. Iglesias’ capability is not easily replaceable, specifically with the team’s current roster uncertainties. The infield situation remains unsettled and they need to decide if they want to focus on proven production over potential stopgaps.

José Iglesias’ 2024 value over Pete Alonso

When comparing their regular-season numbers, Jose Iglesias was more valuable. He finished with a 137 wRC, highlighting that he was roughly 40% better than the league-average hitter. In addition, his .337/.381/.448 slash line proved his capability to get on base and hit for average. On the flip side, Pete Alonso posted a 118 wRC with a .217/.318/.504 slash line. While he slugged 46 home runs, his 29.2% strikeout rate and inconsistency made him less reliable in clutch situations.

As pointed out by John Heyman, “José Iglesias was a more valuable player than Pete Alonso last season, posting a larger WAR and wRC in the regular season.” Iglesias’ 2.5 WAR shows how much he contributed to winning games. In addition, when factoring in defense, Iglesias stays ahead with his multiple infield position plays. But its not just numbers!

José Iglesias fit seamlessly in the Mets’ lineup. “This feels like a foregone conclusion, similar to Pete Alonso. I would be surprised if Iglesias is not in a Mets uniform next season,” shared one of the biggest NYM fan, Tyler (YT: WardyNYM). No matter how uncertain the front office remains, the team is still in need of stability, so, bringing back Iglesias looks like the obvious move.

Why Jose Iglesias’ return is vital for the Mets?

Reunion with Iglesias is required for the Mets. The team lacks a reliable utility infielder. Though Nick Madrigal was added on a split contract, he does not bring the same offensive upside. Josh Iglesias would also serve as a veteran mentor to younger infielders, like, Ronny Mauricio and Jett Williams. His availability could even open up trade possibilities. As WardyNYM highlighted, “Some of these kids become more expendable if the Mets really want to trade for a key starter, like, Cease, Burnes and Castillo.” By securing Iglesias, the Mets could utilize their young infielders as trade pieces to enhance their rotation.

Besides, José Iglesias’ 12.3% strikeout rate in 2024 was among the lowest on the team, compared to Alonso’s 29.2%. His capability to put the ball in play helped sustain rallies, where the Mets struggled last season. The team posted a .247 batting average and finished 23rd in strikeout percentage. And relying too much on Pete Alonso’s streaky power might hurt them offensively. So, if the Mets need a more well-rounded offense, Iglesias should be their top choice.

José Iglesias totally outperformed Pete Alonso last season. His contact hitting, defensive versatility and leadership make him an ideal fit for the Mets. Now, the question is: Will the Mets identify his effectiveness before another team does? Thoughts?