Baseball’s transactional chaos is like a wild rollercoaster. One minute you’re up, the next you’re looking for the next ride. And right now, Dom Smith is back in the spotlight. Once the Mets’ main boy and a young star, he is now a vagabond trying to find his way through MLB’s rough terrain. The whispers? A homecoming. A reunion with Boston’s red tide could be right around the corner.

This is a headache for the Yankees but a sigh of relief for the Red Sox. Dom Smith is making a buzz, and this time, it’s not for his performance. Once chosen by the New York Mets with 11th overall in the 2013 MLB Draft, he therefore started his professional journey. A player full of promise, as shown during the 2020 season cut short by the epidemic when he recorded an outstanding .311 batting average and an amazing .993 OPS, drawing MVP considerations. But the next seasons saw a drop; Smith was unable to match his previous performance, which resulted in his ultimate Mets release. And since then, he has been hopping from one franchise to another.

Looking for stability, he was part of the Boston Red Sox’s offering an olive branch in May 2024, signing Smith to strengthen their lineup after injuries. Later, in January 2025, he signed a minor league deal with the New York Yankees. Now, with opening day approaching, he changed his mind and opted out of the Yankees and thought to join the Red Sox. In the latest update from Boston Sports Grodo on X, “There are some in the Red Sox organization who believe a reunion with Dom Smith may make sense. Dom just opted out of his deal with the Yankees.”

Batting .297 with a .857 OPS over 37 at-bats, his spring training performance was nothing short of outstanding; he reminded everyone of the talent once, making him a top prospect. Notwithstanding these figures, Smith’s participation was difficult given the Yankees’ roster, full of left-handed hitters. Acknowledging the difficult fight, Smith used the opt-out mechanism. Can a reunion with the Red Sox reignite his career, or will this be another fleeting chapter in his unpredictable journey?

The Red Sox connection: A sequel in the making?

They say, “

Once a Red Sox, always a Red Sox,” and that phrase might be about to get a fresh twist. Talks of a reunion are gaining steam, and it’s not hard to see why. In his tenure with the Red Sox, Smith slashed .237/.317/.390 with six home runs and 34 RBIs during his 83-game appearances. His defensive adaptability and clubhouse presence won both supporters and colleagues like me.

Triston Casas, a guy with great promise but a history of injuries that have limited his playing time, anchors the Red Sox’s current first-base situation. Casas showed promise with 13 home runs and a sharp eye at the bat. However, he only showed up in 63 games in 2024. Bringing Smith back may give the Red Sox a consistent insurance policy, guaranteeing depth and experience at the post against this backdrop.

From a financial standpoint, this is a no-brainer. Smith’s 2024 deal with Boston was worth $2.2 million, and signing him at a similar price now would be a low-risk, high-reward move. He’s a familiar face, he knows the system, and he still has the potential to contribute.

Teams are finishing their rosters and making strategic decisions that could define their campaigns as the 2025 MLB season draws near. For Dom Smith, the path has been turbulent, with both hardships and flashes of genius. A possible return to the Boston Red Sox presents a story of continuity and atonement, a means for both organization and player to profit from unresolved business.

For the Red Sox, it’s about shoring up their depth with a player who’s been battle-tested.

So, will this reunion happen? Will Dom Smith finally find stability in Boston?