The Toronto Blue Jays are no stranger to making buzz in the offseason, and this time too, the buzz around the team’s potential moves is growing louder. Moreover, the Blue Jays’ recent signing of Anthony Santander to a five-year, $92.5 million deal has certainly sparked debates, but it seems their offseason isn’t over yet. The Blue Jays front office has set their eyes on not one but two of the biggest names in the market. The question now is- who are these key players, and how might they reshape the Blue Jays’ future?

According to MLB insider Mark Feinsand, the Blue Jays are still exploring potential moves, with two of the most intriguing free agents, Pete Alonso and Max Scherzer, appearing on their radar. Alonso, the impressive first baseman known for his home-run hitting prowess, has been a long member of the New York Mets.

Although the star does not lead the league in batting average, his power numbers speak volumes. He had a satisfactory average of 0.240. Yet, his 34 home runs showcased his hard-hitting ability. The Blue Jays could use some HRs from Pete! His ability to hit massive home runs and change the game with one swing makes him a coveted addition to any team. While Pete’s addition guarantees power, Max’s addition can strengthen the move in the pitching department.

The 40-year-old future Hall of Famer may have dealt with injuries in recent years, but his pedigree and dominance on the mound are undeniable. In 2024, Scherzer posted a 3.95 ERA and a 1.154 WHIP in his time with the Texas Rangers, though he was limited to just nine starts due to back surgery and other injury setbacks.

Despite these challenges, his experience and his proven record as one of the dominant pitchers could make him an intriguing target. While he ensures dominance with his pitching, his ability to perform in high-pressure situations makes him a perfect fit. Adding Max could make the Blue Jays one of the most formidable teams in the league.

While the potential additions of Pete and Max would surely elevate their squad, one critical question remains. What will the Toronto Blue Jays do with Vladimir Guerrero Jr.?

Being the face of the franchise for several years, but with the team’s evolving lineup and shifting roster needs, his long-term role is still a topic of much discussion.

The future of Vladimir Guerrero Jr: a key decision for the Toronto Blue Jays

The additions of Anthony Santander and potentially Pete Alonso made the Toronto Blue Jays fans jump in joy. Amidst all the buzz and excitement over the new signings, there remains a critical question. What will happen with Vladimir Guerrero Jr and his future with the Blue Jays?

Vladdy, who is entering free agency post the 2025 season, has been the face of the franchise since his debut. It’s high time the Jays decide what to do with the 25-year-old slugger.

The Jays must decide whether to lock in the player for a long-term deal or obviously look for trade options before he reaches free agency. The decision is complicated by the fact that Guerrero’s talent and marketability are undeniable—he’s one of the premier power hitters in the league and a cornerstone of Toronto’s lineup.

However, in the team’s pursuit of high-profile players, it’s clear they aim to build a well-rounded roster. Supposedly, if they choose to extend Guerrero, they should be ready to commit to a hefty financial resources to him. On the other hand, if they decide to trade him, they would land a massive return, given Vladdy’s market value and potential.

This situation puts them in a delicate position. Ultimately, the decision to extend or trade Guerrero will define the Blue Jays’ strategy for years to come. Although whatever happens, the move will have massive implications for the team’s future.