Matt Chapman, the free-agent third baseman with Gold Glove pedigree, might have a hidden preference: natural grass. A FanGraphs analysis suggests that his defensive prowess wanes on artificial turf, raising compatibility questions for suitors like the New York Yankees and their lush green field.

Chapman’s defensive metrics dipped after his Oakland A’s tenure, where he played on natural grass, to his latest stint with the Toronto Blue Jays on their AstroTurf field. While factors like the shift ban and aging contribute, the stark contrast remains, making one question several teams’ chances at clinching him, other than the Pinstripes.

Matt Chapman’s turf troubles: Could grass tip the scales in free agency?

On Oakland Athletics’ natural grass territory, Matt Chapman ranked Top 10 in defensive metrics four times in five seasons. On the other hand, later on the Toronto Blue Jays’ turf, he’s hovered around the 7th-best mark, a noticeable drop. 

This raises eyebrows for teams with pristine natural grass. Could Chapman’s defensive edge, a key piece of his value, resurface in familiar territory? FanGraphs poses this as a potential “deciding factor” in his future contract negotiations. 

It is a gamble indeed—but for teams craving defensive stability, the potential reward of a rejuvenated Chapman on grass could be worth the price. After all, as the source concludes—“the margins for a player like this can be thin,” and sometimes, the right playing surface can make all the difference.

Watch This Story: Ranking MLB’s Top 5 Ballparks For Ultimate Fandom

Matt Chapman’s bat still packs a punch, but his glove’s future isn’t as rosy. Age and unforgiving turf, like Toronto’s lone artificial oasis, could dull its shine. For teams like the New York Yankees, with their emerald expanse, it’s a defensive oasis that Chappy would be happy to dive in. So scratch the 5 artificial turf holdouts off Chapman’s dance card–their fans can only dream of a glove reborn on greener pastures.

Chappy’s field of dreams or turf nightmare?

Matt Chapman’s bat is a slugger’s symphony but whispers about his glove’s future are amplified by… fake grass. Five MLB stadiums refuse to join the natural emerald revolution: Arizona Diamondbacks’ Chase Field, Texas Rangers’ Globe Life, Miami Marlins’s LoanDepot Park, Toronto Blue Jays’ Rogers Centre, and Tampa Bay Rays’ Tropicana Field. These plastic kingdoms save on maintenance, but for Chapman, they could spell defensive despair. Players like him see artificial turf as an age-accelerator, turning every groundball into a slow-motion horror show.

Think Yankee Stadium’s lush Kentucky Bluegrass? That’s the magic carpet ride Chapman might be craving. A Bet MBM study revealed natural fields might need a ryegrass patch-up now and then, but for a gloveman like Chapman, there’s nothing like real grass’ consistent bounce and give.

Read More: Yankee Stadium’s Hidden Gems: Exploring the Legendary Home of the New York Yankees Built by Babe Ruth

The right surface could be the difference between a standing ovation and a collective groan. Field of Dreams or Turf Nightmare? Matt Chapman’s landing spot hinges on the answer.