Shohei Ohtani continues to make waves in the news, however this time, the attention has shifted toward his former interpreter, Ippei Mizuhara. Recently, federal prosecutors discredited Mizuhara’s defense by dismissing his gambling addiction allegation and portraying him as a con artist. Even though both Major League Baseball and law enforcement have cleared Ohtani of any misconduct allegations, part of the baseball community is raising doubts about his association with the controversy.

Mizuhara, who emptied nearly $17 million from Ohtani’s account to pay off illegal gambling debts, pleaded guilty to bank fraud and filing a false tax return. While his legal team sought leniency—arguing he was a compulsive gambler under immense stress—federal prosecutors were unconvinced. They pointed to Mizuhara’s strategic impersonation of Ohtani in 24 separate bank transactions over two years, highlighting how he systematically drained the superstar’s finances while maintaining his trust.

Shohei Ohtani’s reputation is under fire despite being cleared

ESPN’s X post gave us a little insight into the lack of evidence for Ippei’s gambling addiction. “There was no evidence Ippei Mizuhara, the ex-interpreter of Shohei Ohtani, suffered from a gambling addiction, as he claimed when he asked a judge to limit his sentence to 18 months.” In contrast, prosecutors argued that Mizuhara didn’t just recklessly gamble away money—he knowingly stole, lied, and even spent on personal luxuries. This wasn’t just addiction; it was betrayal while they pushed for a 57-month prison sentence and full restitution to Ohtani and the IRS.

Major League Baseball swiftly closed its investigation, reaffirming Ohtani’s status as a victim rather than a participant. The league found no evidence linking him to gambling, nor did it uncover any indication that he authorized the payments Mizuhara made on his behalf. But skepticism remains in certain corners of the baseball world.

Outside of Los Angeles, some opposing fans are refusing to give Shohei Ohtani the benefit of the doubt. New York Yankees and San Francisco Giants supporters, in particular, have fueled online discussions, suggesting that his spotless image is “too good to be true.” Some even claim the league had a vested interest in protecting Ohtani to maintain its growing global appeal, particularly in Japan.

How does someone lose $17 million and not notice? One critic posted on social media. Others speculate that Ohtani’s decision to not press charges suggests he may have known more than he let on. While these theories lack concrete evidence, they persist in online debates, casting doubt on the two-time MVP’s reputation.

Rival fan bases keep the controversy alive

There are speculations that the Dodgers may secretly have evidence linking Shohei Ohtani to gambling but are withholding it until his deferred salary begins. Releasing it at that point would enable them to claim a breach of contract and avoid paying him. The theory assumes Ohtani was not a victim but complicit in the scandal, and that the Dodgers, despite signing him to a massive contract, might eventually use this information to escape financial obligations.

Some comments suggested a strong belief that Shohei Ohtani is guilty of gambling, asserting that anyone who has experience with betting or gambling should recognize his supposed involvement. Fans even tried to point out that those who believe Ohtani is innocent are naive or foolish, implying that people who question this view are disconnected from the reality of gambling.

One user wished for Shohei Ohtani’s ban similar to Pete Rose’s, who was permanently suspended from baseball for alleged gambling. They imply that MLB and ESPN might be hesitant to take action against Ohtani due to his immense popularity in Japan, indicating his global influence. The reference to Japan’s “undefeated World War championship record” is likely meant to emphasize the commenter’s belief in the country’s World War history against the USA. Or could it also mean Japan’s significant standing on the recent world stage?

One reaction throws a joke at Ippei Mizuhara, exclaiming that he is getting paid to take the fall in the gambling scandal, with a twist that Ohtani might be the one doling out the payments—perhaps through deferred money. This taunt plays off the idea that Mizuhara is not only absorbing the blame for the fraud but is also getting compensated for it in the same way Ohtani’s contract involves deferred payments.

Some also believe that Ippei Mizuhara might be taking the blame for Ohtani’s actions. But things will unveil when Mizuhara has to decide how far he’s willing to go to protect Ohtani, especially if the legal consequences are severe. This might suggest that loyalty and possible self-interest will come into play as Mizuhara faces serious repercussions.

While the legal system and MLB have cleared Shohei Ohtani, public perception remains divided. As Mizuhara’s sentencing approaches on February 6, one thing is certain—Ohtani’s name isn’t leaving the discussion anytime soon.

Are you on Shohei Ohtani’s side?