

Fielding errors are an unavoidable part of baseball, often brushed off throughout a long season. But when one misplay directly alters the outcome of a game, you may find it at the center of conversation. Now, that’s exactly what unfolded in the recent showdown between the Mets and Dodgers, a tightly contested battle decided by a defensive lapse.
Well, the moment reignited debate around defensive execution, but Mets manager Carlos Mendoza didn’t add fuel to the fire. Instead, he offered a calm, measured response to the costly misplay, putting the focus on growth rather than blame. If you remember, it was Brandon Nimmo’s misjudgment of the fly ball by Freddie Freeman that helped the latter to complete his base run.
So, while the blame is expectedly on Nimmo, Mendoza shared his take. “Not an easy play, especially in that situation,” Mendoza said after the game. “He’s playing shallower than normal, and that’s a tough play in left field for a lefty. It’s over your head. Playing in right there, not an easy play.”
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad
"It's not an easy play"
Carlos Mendoza talks about what happened with Brandon Nimmo on Freddie Freeman's fly ball in the 10th inning: pic.twitter.com/F95UYs3SsF
— SNY (@SNYtv) June 4, 2025
Well, the Mets manager might be correct about the tough play in left field. If you are aware, for lefties in left field, the angles and footwork don’t come as naturally. Reading the ball off the bat, turning the right way, and adjusting the glove side all add up to a steeper learning curve.
Nimmo also gave his take on the misplay, reinforcing what manager Carlos Mendoza had said. Yes, the outfield was positioned shallow in hopes of cutting off a potential run at the plate on a base hit.
“Unfortunately, sometimes that happens. Sometimes, the ball doesn’t go the way you think.”
What’s your perspective on:
Did Brandon Nimmo's misplay cost the Mets the game, or was it just bad luck?
Have an interesting take?
If you have checked the game or highlights, you can see how Nimmo initially tracked the ball over his right shoulder as he sprinted toward the wall. But when he glanced back to check his distance from the fence, the tables were turned. It just took a split second for the ball to drift about 15 feet over his left shoulder.
Now we can surely consider it a classic case of how even a momentary adjustment in the outfield can turn a playable ball into a game-altering miss.
So, while the fly ball was misplayed by error, it was enough for the Dodgers to get away with the win from the Mets. The misplay happened during a 5-5 scoreboard, when the Dodgers walked off with a 6-5 record.
The Mets and Dodgers offered another episode of intense baseball
The midfield was so unpredictable that even Freeman believed it to be a home run. Even the stands started cheering for the home run. We can see how Freeman was standing, hoping the ball to get over the fence.
“I thought it to be honest, but I was just kind of running and hoping it went out cause I knew I hit it high.”
The high hit taken by Freeman was convincing enough to make it a home run. But you know what followed then. However, before Freeman stole the limelight, it was Max Muncy who turned the tables against the Mets.
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad
It was a cherishing moment on the stands when the Dodgers fans started vacating the stadium. However, no one would have expected any more drama left in the game before Muncy took a chance. Well, Muncy made sure of that, crushing a solo homer, his second of the night, to tie the game in the ninth.
Riding a hot streak, Muncy notched his fifth home run of the homestand. He pushed the game into extra innings for the second night in a row. But the real fireworks now came in the bottom of the 10th, when Freeman came through with a walk-off single to left, bringing home Tommy Edman for the winning run.
So, the Dodgers and their comeback stories are becoming too common this season. The 6–5 victory against the Mets marked the Dodgers’ 20th comeback win of the season.
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad
Now that the series is tied 1-1, all eyes are on the next game to witness some more intense actions.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Did Brandon Nimmo's misplay cost the Mets the game, or was it just bad luck?