The Toronto Blue Jays are raining on Pete Alonso’s parade. The New York Mets star’s standing with his team moving forward is already unclear, and the Canadian team has made a move by signing Anthony Santander to a five-year deal worth $90 million. This decision has resonated throughout the league, raising questions. A Mets insider reportedly emphasized the harsh reality Alonso faces as he seeks a long-term extension amid changing market dynamics.

Santander, while a reliable hitter and solid defensive outfielder, has never matched Alonso’s elite power numbers. Yet, his significant payday could complicate Alonso’s case for a bigger deal, as it signals a willingness by teams to reward well-rounded contributors over one-dimensional power. For Alonso, whose value is built almost exclusively on his bat, this reality may leave him struggling to find the long-term security he seeks.

One Mets insider Marc Luino delivered a blunt assessment of Alonso’s situation on X summing it up in four chilling words: “Pete Alonso is actually fu-ked.” The statement encapsulates the mounting pressure Alonso faces as the Mets deliberate on whether to lock up their star slugger or let him test free agency after 2025. Santander, a consistent but less-celebrated bat than Alonso, just secured a significant payday. That deal raises questions about Alonso’s market value and whether New York is prepared to match or exceed it.

Pete Alonso, a two-time Home Run Derby champion and perennial power threat, would command a substantial contract if the Mets decide to extend him. But with the team already committing heavily to other players, such as the $500+ million acquisition of Juan Soto, the organization’s willingness to invest further in Alonso remains unclear. The Santander deal, however, could complicate negotiations by setting a precedent that leans in Alonso’s favor.

While Santander may not match Alonso in power, having never exceeded 33 home runs in a season compared to Alonso’s career high of 53, his contract illustrates the team’s appreciation for versatile players who excel in defense, provide stability to the lineup, and contribute effectively overall. Alonso’s bat might be more potent, but his defensive limitations and streaky performance could give the Mets pause when considering a long-term contract.

Compounding the issue is New York’s reluctance to prioritize Pete Alonso’s future in a rapidly evolving roster. After acquiring Soto and overhauling their outfield, the Mets may feel they have enough offensive firepower to survive without their homegrown slugger. Meanwhile, Alonso’s price tag—likely north of $150 million—may exceed what the team is willing to allocate.

Options for Pete Alonso beyond New York

If Pete Alonso’s status with the Mets stays up in the air many teams across the league might see him as a player for their team strategy moving. One appealing option could be the Chicago Cubs since they are eager to be contenders in the league. Alonso’s incredible power would definitely shine at Wrigley Field, with his home runs boosting their offensive game. The San Francisco Giants might also be excited to bring Alonso on board as a player, for their team to address their batting challenges and envision his home runs making a splash in McCovey Cove.

Other potential suitors could include the Seattle Mariners, who might see Alonso as the big bat needed to complement their young core, or even the Texas Rangers, whose recent investments in star players show a willingness to make bold moves. Alonso’s appeal goes beyond his power; his energy and persona would make him a fan favorite wherever he lands. If the Mets fail to lock him up, it’s likely they’ll be watching their homegrown slugger light up another team’s ballpark for years to come.

While Pete Alonso’s production speaks for itself, the Mets’ ambitious spending spree has shifted priorities. The decision will define the franchise’s direction and its commitment to Alonso as a cornerstone.