Long Before Settling Down With Hannah Davis, Derek Jeter Once Made an Embarrassing Error With One of His Dates

Derek Jeter was a brilliant player and even an excellent leader in the ballparks. But apart from all these things, the former Yankees captain also hit headlines because of his several relationships.

Before getting engaged and then married Hannah Davis, Jeter dated quite a few Hollywood a-listers, including Minka Kelly, Mariah Carey, Jessica Alba, Jessica Biel, and the list goes on. But unlike other celebrities, Jeter always kept his public image clean despite having such famous relationships. 

Derek Jeter reportedly gifted the same gift basket twice to one of his former hookups

As earlier mentioned, Derek Jeter used to gift a special gift basket to say goodbye to all the ladies he dated. Although Jeter never admitted to doing this tradition, one of his exes’ pal confirmed the Yankees legend would gift signed baseballs as memorabilia to his exes.

But one time Derek Jeter, AKA Mr. Clean, may have made a mistake. A New York Post report from 2016 said that Jeter mistakenly gifted the same gift basket twice to one lady.

Read more: Does Derek Jeter Do Yoga? 48-Year-Old Yankees Legend Tells the Truth About an Essential $85 Item

“This summer, he ended up hooking up with a girl who he had hooked up with once before, but Jeter seemed to have forgotten about the first time and gave her the same identical parting gift, a gift basket with a signed Derek Jeter baseball,” the source said to the NY Post in 2016.

“He basically gave her the same gift twice because he’d forgotten hooking up with her the first time!”

Jeter is a doting husband and father

Although Jeter dated several women during his younger days, once he committed to the Swimsuit model Hannah Davis, he has always been by her side. After meeting through a common friend in 2012, Jeter dated Hannah for a few years.

WATCH THIS STORY: From Alex Rodriguez To Derek Jeter: Here Are The Top-5 Richest MLB Players Of All Time

Later, in 2015, Jeter and Hannah got engaged, and the next year, the two tied the knot. Currently, a father of three lovely daughters, Jeter is enjoying his married life with Hannah Davis.

What changes do you see between the young Jeter and his current version?