Insider Unveils New York Yankees’ Blame Game Behind the Plate—Players, Coaches, Boone, or Steinbrenner at fault?

The New York Yankees, a team synonymous with offensive firepower, find themselves in unfamiliar territory this season—in an offensive slump. Despite boasting a star-studded lineup with the likes of Aaron Judge and Anthony Rizzo, runs have been coming at a premium. So, who’s wearing the black hat for this offensive famine? Let’s delve into the Yankees’ very own blame game, one that’s pointing fingers in all directions—from the batters’ box to the coaching staff—and even reaching the owner’s suite in between.

The easiest target in any slump is often the player. After all, they’re the ones swinging the bats and putting the bat on the ball (or whiffing entirely). But as Yankees fan Jay pointed out during a segment on “The Michael Kay Show,” this generation of Bombers is apparently wired to win.

They have dedicated their lives to honing their skills, and a lack of effort is rarely the culprit. So, is there something the coaching staff might be missing?

Michael Kay, the show’s host, highlights the New York Yankees’ “step” to address the offensive woes. They fired hitting coach Dillon Lawson, then replaced him with Sean Casey, and then brought in James Rowson. However, as Kay argues, it’s unfair to expect a complete turnaround after just “27 games”—as Kay pointed out—under a new coach.

Kay doesn’t hesitate from asking controversial questions that might have been nagging quite a few fans’ minds—”Is it James Rowson’s fault that Gleyber Torres hasn’t hit? Is it James Rowson’s fault that Aaron Judge has not been Aaron Judge? I mean, is it James Rowson’s fault that Anthony Rizzo has not been Anthony Rizzo? I mean, you gotta say it’s his fault about Austin Wells too?” But therein lies a different question—are the coaches effectively utilizing the players’ talents, or is there a deeper issue at play?

This line of thinking leads us to Aaron Boone, the Bombers’ manager—and here’s where things get interesting. As the skipper, Boone shoulders the responsibility for the team’s overall performance, offense included. But as Don La Greca, Kay’s co-host, suggests, some fans might be hesitant to directly criticize Boone.

Enter Dusty Baker, the legendary manager, brought up by Jay as a hypothetical alternative—albeit in a twisted turn of events, as Baker would’ve supposedly made for a better coach than Casey or Lawson, as Jay points out. This, as Kay points out, feels like an indirect shot at Boone’s leadership. “You brought up Dusty Baker if you’re talking about changing the hitting coach,” Kay emphasized. “Dusty Baker’s not a hitting coach! You’re talking about Boone.”

New York Yankees need shared accountability, not a blame game

Let’s not forget the role of analytics in yesterday’s game. Jay mentioned how the Yankees’ focused on “analytics and have it connect with our players better” last season as a reason for firing Dillon. While sabermetrics are a valuable tool, an over-reliance on them could be stifling hitters. Finding the right balance between data and a player’s instincts is crucial.

While the focus is heavily on players and coaches, there’s another layer to this blame game: ownership. The New York Yankees, under the Steinbrenner family’s reign, are known for their aggressive pursuit of big-name talent. But, as the saying goes, throwing money at a problem doesn’t always solve it.

Fan frustration with ownership could be simmering beneath the surface, as evidenced by Jay’s comment about the team needing to “succeed.” However, deciphering the exact role of ownership in the offensive woes is a complex task.

The truth, as with most things in baseball, is likely a complex web of factors. Pointing fingers at a single entity—players, coaches, managers, or ownership—might provide a temporary scapegoat, but it won’t fix the problem. The Yankees need a collective effort—a commitment from the players to execute, the coaches to refine their approach, and ownership to foster a supportive environment. Only then can the Bronx Bombers get back to their offensive dominance and silence the critics in the stands and on the airwaves.