The Chicago Cubs’ trip to Tokyo was tough, with a two-game sweep against the Dodgers. Despite the losses, the team found positives, containing Matt Shaw’s debut and Justin Steele’s milestone strikeout. Now, insider Elise Menaker has made a vital assumption: the entire team outfield will win Gold Gloves in 2025. Given Ian Happ’s track record, Cody Bellinger’s defensive skills, and Pete Crow-Armstrong’s elite fielding potential, it is not impossible. However, past struggles and competition in the NL make this a high-risk call.

The Chicago Cubs have established a defensively sound outfield. Ian Happ has already earned two Gold Gloves, in 2022 and 2023, and has solidified himself as a reliable left fielder. Cody Bellinger, while basically a center fielder and first baseman, has a past Gold Glove and remains a powerful defensive availability. In addition, Pete Crow-Armstrong, a rookie with elite defensive scouting grades, has the power to break out in his first full MLB season.

Their defensive metrics support this prediction. In 2024, Happ posted 11 Defensive Runs Saved. In that year, Bellinger recorded a solid Outs Above Average at center, and PCA’s minor-league defensive image suggests a Gold Glove ceiling. If the Chicago Cubs manage consistency, Menaker’s call could not be as outlandish as it sounds. Winning a Gold Glove is not just related to being good—it’s about outperforming others. The National League outfield has perennial contenders like, Mookie Betts, Fernando Tatís Jr., and Brenton Doyle. They all are elite defenders. For all three Cubs outfielders to win, they need to not only excel individually but also outshine this tough competition.

Historically speaking, having an entire outfield win Gold Gloves is rare. The last team to accomplish it? The 1979 Yankees with Lou Piniella, Mickey Rivers, and Reggie Jackson. The Cubs would need near-perfect defensive seasons from all three to replicate this feat. However, if PCA transitions smoothly and Bellinger stays healthy, there is a legitimate path forward.

Chicago Cubs’ resilience after the Tokyo series

Despite the rough start in Tokyo, the Cubs are focusing on long-term success. Manager Craig Counsell highlighted that while the outcome was not ideal, the team gained valuable experience. Justin Steele, who reached his 500th career strikeout in Tokyo, sees the trip as a learning moment. The Cubs have been in similar situations before—slow starts that turned into successful seasons. In 2023, they struggled early but made a second-half push. If they use this Tokyo experience to sharpen their defensive strategies, it could reinforce their Gold Glove ambitions.

Counsell’s teams have historically emphasized defense. During his time with the Brewers, his outfielders consistently ranked among the best in defensive effectiveness. Now, with the Cubs, his effect could elevate their fielding performance further. If Counsell’s system optimizes defensive positioning and PCA’s availability enhances outfield range, the Cubs’ outfield Gold Glove potential grows. 

Their capability to recover from the Tokyo losses will also showcase their defensive resilience—vital aspects needed for this prediction to come true. Elise Menaker’s prediction is bold but not impossible. The Cubs’ defensive talent, coaching influence, and Tokyo experience could set them up for a historic Gold Glove sweep. However, competition remains fierce.

Can they prove the doubters wrong? Do you think the Cubs’ outfield can make history? Let us know your take below.