“I Was Going to Steal You Away From…”- Derek Jeter Once Left Troubled Ex-Girlfriend Mariah Carey Excited With a Bold Plan

The charismatic personality of Derek Jeter made him an influential figure in baseball. Outside the ballpark, he commanded the same amount of respect for his attitude. His sporting success further increased his charm. So it’s no wonder that he dated many high-profile women. 

Jeter is a legendary baseball icon and a highly treasured athlete. Playing as the New York Yankees shortstop for his whole MLB career, he became a poster hero. In his epic playing tenure, the 14-time All-Star Jeter won five World Series championships. Therefore, with such glorious records to boast, he was very much a commendable presence. 

With his leadership abilities, Jeter victoriously guided the Yankees in the field for about two decades. He was the type of player who could make things happen. That influential aspect of him carried over from his profession into his personal life, too. He once made a grand plan of eloping with his then-girlfriend, pop music sensation Mariah Carey. 

Derek Jeter and Mariah Carey had a liberating fairytale romance 

Derek Jeter has a long history of dating celebrity women, just as many legendary athletes do. However, most of those pairings were brief. Likewise, Jeter once dated the famous Mariah Carey. The two of them were together only for about a year. 

Jeter and Carey met each other in 1997 and began dating. Notably, Carey was still married to music executive Tommy Mottola at that time. However, Carey was, reportedly, largely unhappy in her marriage and was looking for a way out. So Jeter, who was already highly fond of Carey, turned out to be the life-changing relationship in her life. 

Long before Jeter turned into a baseball star, Carey was already a world-renowned musician. Jeter was a big fan of Carey and had the dream of marrying her one day.

Carey recalled in her memoir titled, ‘The Meaning of Mariah Carey,’ how Jeter had a grand plan. Jeter, who had a nickname for Carey’s then-husband, told Carey, “I was going to meet you, and I was going to steal you away from Tony Sony.”

Read More – Mariah Carey Gave Every Reason but Then Boyfriend Derek Jeter to Explain One of Her Record-Breaking Favorites of All-Time

In Carey’s words, Jeter had the desire to go to New York and play for the Yankees. From there on, he planned to meet Carey and steal her away from her husband. 

What became of the fairytale romance? 

Jeter and Carey separated in a very short time. But Carey found the much-needed courage to sever ties with her shaky marriage. Thus, Carey honored Jeter with two songs and also mentioned him in her memoir. 

Watch This Story – From Babe Ruth To Derek Jeter: New York Yankees Legends Whose Jersey Number Has Been Retired 

Do you think Derek Jeter and Mariah Carey would have made a great couple if they stayed together?