Doug Mientkiewicz, a former World Series winner, recently shared a bold perspective on the New York Yankees’ handling of Juan Soto and how their inaction may have propelled the star outfielder to their rival, the New York Mets. Mientkiewicz claims that during the 2024 World Series, particularly Game 2, Soto’s body language revealed that he was “done” with carrying the weight of his team’s offense.

Mientkiewicz’s assessment wasn’t merely about Soto’s statistics but about his emotional and physical exhaustion. Despite maintaining his high level of play, Soto appeared drained. For a player of his caliber, it’s frustrating to be isolated in an underperforming lineup, and this contributed to Soto’s decision to sign a $765 million deal with the Mets.

Mientkiewicz’s critique of the Yankees’ strategy

Foul Territory posted a clip of Doug Mientkiewicz on X, talking about the New York Yankees’ lack of action being the reason for Juan Soto’s miss. Doug said, “I think if you read Juan Soto’s face in the World Series, Game 2, he looked like he was done. It almost looked like I’ve done everything I could possibly do, I just need a little help. And he wasn’t getting it.” He added Soto continued to have strong at-bats and played well, but it was as if he was completely drained.

Choosing the Mets over the New York Yankees came as a setback for the Bronx Bombers despite their evident interest. Mientkiewicz’s assessment pointed out flaws in the Yankees’ plan—they were so focused on improving their pitching areas that they overlooked the requirement for a power hitter, like Soto. Meanwhile, the Mets, eager to make a statement after a turbulent season, moved quickly, presenting Soto with an offer the Yankees couldn’t match in urgency or vision.

The $765 million price tag on Soto’s contract may have seemed daunting, but Mientkiewicz argues that it was a necessary move to shift the Mets’ fortunes. The Yankees seemed more interested in making a splash than finding a lasting fix. A strategy that ended up benefiting their local opponents across town.

Top Comment by Bob

The Yankees have too many holes to fill to spend that much on one player, so thank you, Steve Cohen...more

Share your take

Debate

Soto’s arrival on the Mets brings implications for both sides into focus. Now, the Mets have placed themselves in a position to challenge the New York Yankees. Not only in the standings but in the broader New York baseball rivalry.

Max Fried and the club’s long-term concerns

Max Fried’s arrival in New York was a significant move for the Yankees, bolstering their rotation with an established ace. However, lingering concerns about his durability, especially following his history with Tommy John surgery, could pose challenges in the long term. Fried’s previous recovery was impressive, but the Yankees’ medical staff has long been wary of the typical five-to-six-year post-Tommy John window, which suggests that pitchers may experience a decline in performance or face further injuries. With Fried entering what could be his third year after surgery, questions remain about his ability to maintain peak performance, especially under the intense demands of a Yankees roster expected to contend for championships.

The New York Yankees may have to navigate the uncertainty surrounding Fried’s future health while balancing their rotation’s needs. While his skill set and experience make him a valuable asset, the team may need to be cautious with his workload and monitor his health closely to avoid a scenario where they lose their investment in the long run.

The Yankees’ hesitation to pursue Soto and concerns over Fried’s durability could prove costly in the long run. As both teams prepare for the 2025 season, the balance of power in the city remains in play.

Who do you think will snatch the attention this season? Keep those thoughts coming in!