Will Pete Alonso re-sign with the Mets, or will he don a new jersey next season? This question has been on the minds of Alonso fans for quite some time. As the offseason progresses, the market for first basemen has begun to shrink, with many teams already addressing their needs at the position. However, the Angels and Giants have emerged as potential landing spots for the slugger.

The longer Alonso remains unsigned, the more his market value could take a hit. This could tempt teams like the Angels, who may see an opportunity to secure one of the league’s top first basemen at a relatively lower price. Despite this, there remains a strong sentiment among Mets fans and analysts that Alonso belongs in New York. Even MLB insider Ken Rosenthal has voiced his belief that the Mets could—and should—bring Alonso back, citing his rare skill set and value to the franchise.

Insider points to a rare quality exhibited by ‘The Polar Bear’

On a recent episode of the Foul Territory podcast, senior insider Ken Rosenthal addressed the ongoing Pete Alonso situation. Rosenthal stated, “I still see the Mets as the logical place here and you’re gonna hear about other teams, whatever. I don’t know if any of those are that real.”

Rosenthal acknowledged that teams like the Angels or Giants, who have reportedly shown interest, could make a move for Alonso. However, he remains adamant that the Mets are the best fit. His reasoning is simple: the Mets are the team that developed Alonso and provided the environment where the first baseman has thrived. Along with that, what works in Pete’s favor is the fact that he can play in the New York market. Not many players can do that, and Alonso possesses that rare quality.

The only issue that is keeping the Mets and maybe the other teams too from making him an offer is the age factor. Alonso is entering his 30s. That is not a time when a player is in his prime. Plus, ‘The Polar Bear’ is hardly an athletic guy. Sure he works out from time to time, but teams do not want to commit long-term to players having a profile like Alonso. But if not him, then who?

Top Comment by NY Mets 25

Again,the Mets will make a mistake letting home-grown talent get away.Seaver,Ryan,Strawberry….should I continue…?? Let us not repeat the past or...more

Share your take

Debate

The Mets must acknowledge some difficult questions amid Pete Alonso’s situation 

There are a few different avenues they could pursue to fill the void at first base. The first option would likely be exploring the trade market for another established first baseman, especially if Pete Alonso ends up elsewhere. This would give them an immediate replacement and keep their lineup intact. However, where Alonso lands could influence the trade options, so that situation would be fluid.

A trade could also help the Mets address other areas of need, depending on what they would have to give up. Another potential route would be to get creative within their system. If the Mets aren’t able or willing to go after a big-name free agent or trade target, they might turn to internal options. Moving someone like Mark Vientos from third base to first is a possibility, but the Mets would likely want to balance that with keeping a solid presence at the hot corner. That’s where Brett Baty and Ronny Mauricio come into play.

If they feel confident in those players’ abilities to handle third base full-time, they might give them an extended look, and this would free up first base for Vientos, who has shown promise with his bat. Ultimately, the Mets may find their answer internally, especially with a new front-office focus on developing young talent.

But if they’re serious about competing for a title in 2025, they may still seek an external option to solidify the infield. Do you think the Mets should reunite with Pete Alonso or look somewhere else? Drop your views in the comment section below!